Crites Gerald E, Gaines Julie K, Cottrell Scott, Kalishman Summers, Gusic Maryellen, Mavis Brian, Durning Steven J
GRU/UGA Medical Partnership , USA .
Med Teach. 2014 Aug;36(8):657-74. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2014.916791. Epub 2014 Jun 26.
Abstract This AMEE Guide provides an overview of medical education scholarship for early career scholars, based upon a summary of the existing literature and pragmatic advice derived from the experience of its authors. After providing an introduction to the principles of scholarship and describing questions that the Guide addresses, the authors offer a conceptual description of the complementary traditions of teaching and educational discovery, and advocate for the development of educational scholars with both traditions. They then describe the attributes of effective mentor-mentee relationships and how early career scholars can identify potential mentors who can fulfill this role. In the subsequent sections, they describe the appropriate development of scholarly questions and other components of a complete scholarly plan, including how to use conceptual frameworks in guiding such plans. From here, they describe methods that align with both the teaching and discovery traditions and provide concrete examples of each. They then provide guidelines for assessing the impact of scholarship, identify the various opportunities for sharing it, and how to effectively interpret and describe it. Additionally, they provide practical advice on how appropriately to demonstrate the scholarship in a promotional packet, including the principle of reflectivity in scholarship. Finally, they address the principles of applied research ethics for educational scholarship and when to consider soliciting approval for scholarly activities by a human research board.
摘要 本AMEE指南基于现有文献综述以及作者经验得出的实用建议,为初入职场的学者提供医学教育学术研究概述。在介绍学术研究原则并描述本指南所涉及的问题之后,作者对教学与教育探索这两种互补传统进行了概念性描述,并倡导培养兼具这两种传统的教育学者。接着,他们描述了有效的导师-学员关系的特点,以及初入职场的学者如何识别能够胜任这一角色的潜在导师。在随后的章节中,他们阐述了学术问题的合理构建以及完整学术计划的其他组成部分,包括如何运用概念框架来指导此类计划。在此基础上,他们介绍了与教学和探索传统相契合的方法,并给出了每种方法的具体示例。然后,他们提供了评估学术研究影响力的指导原则,确定了分享研究成果的各种机会,以及如何有效地解读和描述研究成果。此外,他们还就如何在宣传资料中恰当地展示学术研究提供了实用建议,包括学术研究中的反思原则。最后,他们阐述了教育学术研究的应用研究伦理原则,以及何时应考虑寻求人类研究委员会对学术活动的批准。