Veeroo Helen J, Cunningham Susan J, Newton Jonathon Timothy, Travess Helen C
Specialty registrar, Orthodontic Department, Stoke Mandeville Hospital, Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire; postgraduate student, University College London Eastman Dental Institute, London, United Kingdom.
Professor and program director, Department of Orthodontics, University College London Eastman Dental Institute, London, United Kingdom.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2014 Jul;146(1):33-9. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2014.03.021.
Intraoral elastics are commonly used in orthodontics and require regular changing to be effective. Unfortunately, poor compliance with elastics is often encountered, especially in adolescents. Intention for an action and its implementation can be improved using "if-then" plans that spell out when, where, and how a set goal, such as elastic wear, can be put into action. Our aim was to determine the effect of if-then plans on compliance with elastics.
To identify common barriers to compliance with recommendations concerning elastic wear, semistructured interviews were carried out with 14 adolescent orthodontic patients wearing intraoral elastics full time. Emerging themes were used to develop if-then plans to improve compliance with elastic wear. A prospective pilot study assessed the effectiveness of if-then planning aimed at overcoming the identified barriers on compliance with elastic wear. Twelve participants were randomized equally into study and control groups; the study group received information about if-then planning. The participants were asked to collect used elastics, and counts of these were used to assess compliance.
A wide range of motivational and volitional factors were described by the interviewed participants, including the perceived benefits of elastics, cues to remember, pain, eating, social situations, sports, loss of elastics, and breakages. Compliance with elastic wear was highly variable among patients. The study group returned more used elastics, suggesting increased compliance, but the difference was not significant.
The use of if-then plans might improve compliance with elastic wear when compared with routine clinical instructions.
口内弹力牵引装置在正畸治疗中常用,且需定期更换才能有效。遗憾的是,患者对弹力牵引装置的依从性往往较差,尤其是青少年。使用“如果-那么”计划可以提高行为意图及其实施效果,该计划详细说明了何时、何地以及如何将诸如佩戴弹力牵引装置这样的既定目标付诸行动。我们的目的是确定“如果-那么”计划对弹力牵引装置依从性的影响。
为了确定弹力牵引装置佩戴建议依从性的常见障碍,我们对14名全天佩戴口内弹力牵引装置的青少年正畸患者进行了半结构式访谈。根据出现的主题制定“如果-那么”计划,以提高弹力牵引装置佩戴的依从性。一项前瞻性试点研究评估了旨在克服已确定障碍的“如果-那么”计划对弹力牵引装置佩戴依从性的有效性。12名参与者被平均随机分为研究组和对照组;研究组收到有关“如果-那么”计划的信息。要求参与者收集用过的弹力牵引装置,并通过统计其数量来评估依从性。
受访参与者描述了广泛的动机和意志因素,包括对弹力牵引装置的感知益处、记忆线索、疼痛、饮食、社交场合、运动、弹力牵引装置丢失和破损。患者之间弹力牵引装置佩戴的依从性差异很大。研究组返还的用过的弹力牵引装置更多,表明依从性有所提高,但差异不显著。
与常规临床指导相比,使用“如果-那么”计划可能会提高弹力牵引装置佩戴的依从性。