Avadí Angel, Fréon Pierre, Tam Jorge
Université Montpellier 2- Sciences et Techniques, Montpellier, France; Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), UMR212 EME IFREMER/IRD/UM2, Sète, France.
Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), UMR212 EME IFREMER/IRD/UM2, Sète, France.
PLoS One. 2014 Jul 8;9(7):e102057. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0102057. eCollection 2014.
Sustainability assessment of food supply chains is relevant for global sustainable development. A framework is proposed for analysing fishfood (fish products for direct human consumption) supply chains with local or international scopes. It combines a material flow model (including an ecosystem dimension) of the supply chains, calculation of sustainability indicators (environmental, socio-economic, nutritional), and finally multi-criteria comparison of alternative supply chains (e.g. fates of landed fish) and future exploitation scenarios. The Peruvian anchoveta fishery is the starting point for various local and global supply chains, especially via reduction of anchoveta into fishmeal and oil, used worldwide as a key input in livestock and fish feeds. The Peruvian anchoveta supply chains are described, and the proposed methodology is used to model them. Three scenarios were explored: status quo of fish exploitation (Scenario 1), increase in anchoveta landings for food (Scenario 2), and radical decrease in total anchoveta landings to allow other fish stocks to prosper (Scenario 3). It was found that Scenario 2 provided the best balance of sustainability improvements among the three scenarios, but further refinement of the assessment is recommended. In the long term, the best opportunities for improving the environmental and socio-economic performance of Peruvian fisheries are related to sustainability-improving management and policy changes affecting the reduction industry. Our approach provides the tools and quantitative results to identify these best improvement opportunities.
食品供应链的可持续性评估对全球可持续发展至关重要。本文提出了一个框架,用于分析具有地方或国际范围的鱼类食品(直接供人类消费的鱼类产品)供应链。该框架结合了供应链的物质流模型(包括生态系统维度)、可持续性指标(环境、社会经济、营养)的计算,以及最终对替代供应链(如上岸鱼类的去向)和未来开发情景的多标准比较。秘鲁鳀鱼渔业是各种地方和全球供应链的起点,特别是通过将秘鲁鳀鱼加工成鱼粉和鱼油,这些产品在全球范围内用作牲畜和鱼类饲料的关键原料。文中描述了秘鲁鳀鱼供应链,并使用所提出的方法对其进行建模。探讨了三种情景:鱼类开发现状(情景1)、增加用于食品的秘鲁鳀鱼上岸量(情景2),以及大幅减少秘鲁鳀鱼总上岸量以使其他鱼类种群繁荣(情景3)。研究发现,情景2在三种情景中提供了最佳的可持续性改善平衡,但建议进一步完善评估。从长远来看,改善秘鲁渔业环境和社会经济绩效的最佳机会与影响鱼粉加工业的可持续性改善管理和政策变化有关。我们的方法提供了工具和定量结果,以确定这些最佳改善机会。