Good Marie, Inzlicht Michael, Larson Michael J
Psychology Department, Redeemer University College, Ancaster, ON, Canada, L9K 1J4, Psychology Department, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, MiC 1A4 and Psychology Department, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, USA, 84602
Psychology Department, Redeemer University College, Ancaster, ON, Canada, L9K 1J4, Psychology Department, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, MiC 1A4 and Psychology Department, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, USA, 84602.
Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2015 Mar;10(3):357-63. doi: 10.1093/scan/nsu096. Epub 2014 Jul 25.
In religions where God is portrayed as both loving and wrathful, religious beliefs may be a source of fear as well as comfort. Here, we consider if God's love may be more effective, relative to God's wrath, for soothing distress, but less effective for helping control behavior. Specifically, we assess whether contemplating God's love reduces our ability to detect and emotionally react to conflict between one's behavior and overarching religious standards. We do so within a neurophysiological framework, by observing the effects of exposure to concepts of God's love vs punishment on the error-related negativity (ERN)--a neural signal originating in the anterior cingulate cortex that is associated with performance monitoring and affective responses to errors. Participants included 123 students at Brigham Young University, who completed a Go/No-Go task where they made 'religious' errors (i.e. ostensibly exhibited pro-alcohol tendencies). Reflecting on God's love caused dampened ERNs and worse performance on the Go/No-Go task. Thinking about God's punishment did not affect performance or ERNs. Results suggest that one possible reason religiosity is generally linked to positive well-being may be because of a decreased affective response to errors that occurs when God's love is prominent in the minds of believers.
在那些将上帝描绘为既慈爱又愤怒的宗教中,宗教信仰可能既是恐惧的来源,也是慰藉的来源。在此,我们探讨相对于上帝的愤怒而言,上帝的爱对于舒缓痛苦是否更有效,但在帮助控制行为方面是否效果较差。具体而言,我们评估思考上帝的爱是否会降低我们察觉自身行为与总体宗教标准之间的冲突并对其产生情绪反应的能力。我们在神经生理学框架内开展此项研究,通过观察接触上帝之爱与惩罚的概念对错误相关负波(ERN)的影响来进行——ERN是一种源自前扣带回皮质的神经信号,与绩效监测以及对错误的情感反应相关。参与者包括123名杨百翰大学的学生,他们完成了一项“Go/No-Go”任务,在任务中他们犯了“宗教性”错误(即表面上表现出亲酒倾向)。思考上帝的爱会导致ERN减弱以及在“Go/No-Go”任务中的表现变差。思考上帝的惩罚则不会影响表现或ERN。结果表明,宗教信仰通常与积极的幸福感相关联的一个可能原因或许是,当上帝的爱在信徒心中占据显著位置时,他们对错误的情感反应会减弱。