Omama Shinichi, Yoshida Yuki, Ogasawara Kuniaki, Ogawa Akira, Ishibashi Yasuhiro, Nakamura Motoyuki, Tanno Kozo, Ohsawa Masaki, Onoda Toshiyuki, Itai Kazuyoshi, Sakata Kiyomi
Department of Critical Care Medicine, Iwate Medical University, Morioka, Japan.
Cerebrovasc Dis. 2014;37(6):451-9. doi: 10.1159/000363278. Epub 2014 Jul 26.
Several studies have reported on increases in the incidence of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases after huge earthquakes. An increase in the incidence of cerebrovascular diseases was observed after the Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami of 2011. To assess whether tsunami damage or the earthquake was responsible for this trend, we assessed the relative impact of earthquake magnitude and flood damage on cerebrovascular disease.
A total of 12 coastal municipalities facing the epicenter were divided into 4 flood severity groups according to the percentage of people living in the flooded areas (<20, 20-40, 40-60, and ≥60%) and 3 groups according to the Japanese Meteorological Agency seismic intensity of the main shock (<4.5, 4.5-5.0 and ≥5.0). The standard incidence ratios (SIRs) of cerebrovascular diseases in the first 4 weeks after the disaster compared with the same periods in 2008-2010 were calculated for each flood severity group and each earthquake severity group. Odds ratios (ORs) of disease incidence and the adjusted ORs for seismic intensity (using the Mantel-Haenszel method) between the higher (≥40%) and the lower flooded area (<40%) were compared with the same periods in 2008-2010. Likewise, ORs and adjusted ORs for flood severity in the high seismic intensity area (≥4.9) were compared with those in the low seismic intensity area (<4.9).
SIRs increased with the increased flood severity: 0.94 (0.59-1.30) at <20%, 1.02 (0.70-1.34) at 20-40%, 1.26 (0.66-1.86) at 40-60% and 1.98 (1.25-2.72) at ≥60%. However, SIRs did not increase with increased seismic intensity: 0.95 (0.60-1.29) at <4.5, 1.52 (1.07-1.98) at 4.5-5.0 and 1.17 (0.80-1.54) at ≥5.0. ORs and adjusted ORs for seismic intensity in the high flood area compared with the low flood area were significant: 1.68 (1.07-2.65) and 1.78 (1.08-2.96), respectively. However, ORs and adjusted ORs for flood severity in the high seismic intensity area compared with the low intensity area were not significant: 1.33 (0.82-2.17) and 1.19 (0.62-2.31), respectively.
Cerebrovascular disease incidences after the Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami of 2011 increased because of tsunami damage and not because of the earthquake magnitude.
多项研究报告了大地震后心血管和脑血管疾病发病率的上升。2011年东日本大地震及海啸后观察到脑血管疾病发病率有所增加。为评估是海啸破坏还是地震导致了这一趋势,我们评估了地震震级和洪水破坏对脑血管疾病的相对影响。
总共12个面向震中的沿海自治市,根据居住在受洪水影响地区的人口百分比(<20%、20 - 40%、40 - 60%和≥60%)分为4个洪水严重程度组,并根据日本气象厅主震的地震烈度(<4.5、4.5 - 5.0和≥5.0)分为3个组。计算了每个洪水严重程度组和每个地震严重程度组在灾难发生后前4周内脑血管疾病的标准发病率比(SIRs),并与2008 - 2010年同期进行比较。比较了2008 - 2010年同期,高淹没区(≥40%)和低淹没区(<40%)之间疾病发病率的比值比(ORs)以及地震烈度的调整比值比(使用Mantel - Haenszel方法)。同样,比较了高地震烈度区(≥4.9)和低地震烈度区(<4.9)洪水严重程度的ORs和调整ORs。
SIRs随着洪水严重程度的增加而升高:<20%时为0.94(0.59 - 1.30),20 - 40%时为1.02(0.70 - 1.34),40 - 60%时为1.26(0.66 - 1.86),≥60%时为1.98(1.25 - 2.72)。然而,SIRs并未随着地震烈度的增加而升高:<4.5时为0.95(0.60 - 1.29),4.5 - 5.0时为1.52(1.07 - 1.98),≥5.0时为1.17(0.80 - 1.54)。高淹没区与低淹没区相比,地震烈度的ORs和调整ORs具有显著性:分别为1.68(1.07 - 2.65)和1.78(1.08 - 2.96)。然而,高地震烈度区与低烈度区相比,洪水严重程度的ORs和调整ORs不具有显著性:分别为1.33(0.82 - 2.17)和1.19(0.62 - 2.31)。
2011年东日本大地震及海啸后脑血管疾病发病率的增加是由于海啸破坏,而非地震震级。