Matějka J, Skála-Rosenbaum J, Krbec M, Zeman J, Matějka T, Zeman P
Klinika ortopedie a traumatologie pohybového ústrojí LF a FN v Plzni.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2013;80(5):335-40.
Type B3 thoracic and lumbar fractures are often found in spines with previous hyperossification processes such as ankylosing spondylarthritis (AS) or diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH). They occur most frequently due to high-energy trauma in a healthy spine and as fall-related domestic injury in a spine affected by hyperossification. Generally, they are less frequent than type B3 cervical spine fractures. In this retrospective study involving two centres, the incidence of these fractures, their characterisation, therapy and complications associated with them were investigated.
Between March 2003 and March 2012, 21 patients with type B3 injuries (Magerl classification) were treated in our centres. The thoracic spine was involved in 14 and the lumbar spine in seven patients. The patients' average age was 61.8 years, with a range of 33 to 87 years. There were three women and 18 men. Six fractures occurred in previously healthy spines, five and 10 were in AS- and DISH-affected spines, respectively. The evaluation included the mechanism of injury, patient's weight and height, neurological findings, type of treatment and its result, outcome after treatment termination, complications and associated diseases and injuries.
The mechanism of injury differed between the healthy and disease-affected spines. All five AS patients suffered low-energy fractures while patients with previously healthy spines had high-energy injuries. The DISH patients had both low- and high-energy fractures. Type B3.1.1 fractures were diagnosed in two AS patients and six DISH patients, and in no previously healthy patient. Type B3.1.2 fractures were found in one AS patient, two DISH patients and one previously healthy patient. Type B3.2 fracture occurred in one patient with a previously healthy spine, in two AS and two DISH patients. Type B3.3 fractures were in four patients with previously healthy spines. Neurological deficit was found in five injured patients, four of whom had complete paraplegia (Frankel grade A) which did not improve. One AS patient in whom the spinal fracture was associated with Frankel grade C injury improved to Frankel D after surgery. All patients had an elevated BMI, ranging from 25.1 to 41.9; the average value was 32.2, which is within grade 1 obesity. Associated injuries were found in 11 patients, mostly in those with high-energy trauma. Seventeen patients were treated surgically, four conservatively. Posterior stabilisation was carried out in 10 patients who had either AS or DISH conditions; seven patients had a short spinal stabilisation. Complications included early infection in two patients, cerebrospinal fluid fistula in one, urinary tract infection in one and confused state of mind in two patients. All patients healed well but for one patient who died at 4 months after injury due to multiple complications.
In the majority of relevant publications these injuries are reported in patients suffering from hyperossification disorders such as AS or DISH. In patients with healthy spines they occur less frequently and the traumatic hyperextension mechanism must have great intensity. Fractures of a hyperossified spine are related to obesity and this was also confirmed by our study in which all patients were overweight or obese. This factor plays an important role in the hyperextension mechanism that produces a sudden overcoming of the resistance of a spinal segment to force, resulting in a type B3 fracture.
A different approach to these fractures is required in comparison with other spinal fractures. Type B3 fractures have some features common with type C fractures and are frequent in spines affected by spinal disease. In hyperossification disorders, paradoxically associated with advanced osteoporosis, fracture treatment requires long instrumentation. In healthy spines, fractures are treated with short instrumentation. In AS and DISH patients, the diagnosis may be delayed because these patients suffer from chronic spine pain and the pain due to fracture may be attributed to an accelerated chronic condition.
B3型胸腰椎骨折常见于先前存在骨质增生过程的脊柱,如强直性脊柱炎(AS)或弥漫性特发性骨肥厚(DISH)。它们最常因健康脊柱的高能创伤以及骨质增生脊柱的跌倒相关家庭损伤而发生。一般来说,它们比B3型颈椎骨折少见。在这项涉及两个中心的回顾性研究中,调查了这些骨折的发生率、特征、治疗方法以及与之相关的并发症。
2003年3月至2012年3月期间,我们中心共治疗了21例B3型损伤(马格勒分类)患者。其中14例累及胸椎,7例累及腰椎。患者平均年龄为61.8岁,年龄范围为33至87岁。女性3例,男性18例。6例骨折发生在先前健康的脊柱,5例和10例分别发生在AS和DISH受累的脊柱。评估内容包括损伤机制、患者体重和身高、神经学检查结果、治疗类型及其结果、治疗结束后的结局、并发症以及相关疾病和损伤。
健康脊柱和患病脊柱的损伤机制不同。所有5例AS患者均遭受低能量骨折,而先前健康脊柱的患者则遭受高能损伤。DISH患者既有低能量骨折也有高能量骨折。2例AS患者和6例DISH患者被诊断为B3.1.1型骨折,先前健康的患者中未发现此类骨折。1例AS患者、2例DISH患者和1例先前健康的患者被发现为B3.1.2型骨折。1例先前健康脊柱的患者、2例AS患者和2例DISH患者发生了B3.2型骨折。4例先前健康脊柱的患者发生了B3.3型骨折。5例受伤患者出现神经功能缺损,其中4例完全截瘫(Frankel A级)且无改善。1例AS患者的脊柱骨折合并Frankel C级损伤,术后改善为Frankel D级。所有患者的BMI均升高,范围为25.1至41.9;平均值为32.2,属于1级肥胖。11例患者存在相关损伤,大多发生在高能创伤患者中。17例患者接受了手术治疗,4例接受保守治疗。10例患有AS或DISH的患者进行了后路稳定手术;7例患者进行了短节段脊柱稳定手术。并发症包括2例患者早期感染、1例脑脊液漏、1例尿路感染和2例患者精神错乱。所有患者均愈合良好,但1例患者在受伤后4个月因多种并发症死亡。
在大多数相关出版物中,这些损伤报告于患有骨质增生疾病如AS或DISH的患者。在健康脊柱患者中,它们发生频率较低,且创伤性过伸机制必须具有很大强度。骨质增生脊柱的骨折与肥胖有关,我们的研究也证实了这一点,即所有患者均超重或肥胖。该因素在过伸机制中起重要作用,过伸机制会突然克服脊柱节段对力的抵抗力,从而导致B3型骨折。
与其他脊柱骨折相比,这些骨折需要不同的治疗方法。B3型骨折具有一些与C型骨折相同的特征,且在脊柱疾病受累的脊柱中较为常见。在与晚期骨质疏松症矛盾相关的骨质增生疾病中,骨折治疗需要长节段内固定。在健康脊柱中,骨折采用短节段内固定治疗。在AS和DISH患者中,诊断可能会延迟,因为这些患者患有慢性脊柱疼痛,骨折引起的疼痛可能归因于慢性病情加重。