Balarajan R
Epidemiology and Public Health Research Unit, University of Surrey, Guildford.
BMJ. 1989 Sep 30;299(6703):822-5. doi: 10.1136/bmj.299.6703.822.
Mortality among men employed in the health sector was examined using data surrounding the 1971 (1970-2) and 1981 (1979-83) censuses to assess the differences between social classes in the health service and to study changes over a decade. Relative to men in England and Wales, mortality in the 1980s was significantly lower among dentists (standardised mortality ratio 66), doctors (69), opticians (72), and physiotherapists (79) and significantly higher among hospital porters (151), male nurses (118), and ambulancemen (109). Mortality from lung cancer among hospital porters (185) was more than fivefold that seen in doctors (33) and dentists (37). Ischaemic heart disease varied twofold, being lowest in dentists (60) and doctors (70) and highest in hospital porters (138). Over the decade mortality from lung cancer and ischaemic heart disease declined in all groups except hospital porters, ambulancemen, and orderlies. Most groups showed excess deaths from suicides and cirrhosis of the liver. Differences in mortality between health workers in social class I and those in social class IV widened between the 1970s and 1980s and to a greater extent than among the general population. The high mortality of some groups within the NHS, and the fact that differentials between social classes have widened more than in the general population, suggest that the NHS needs to pay more attention to the health of its own staff.
利用1971年(1970 - 1972年)和1981年(1979 - 1983年)人口普查数据,对卫生部门就业男性的死亡率进行了研究,以评估卫生服务领域不同社会阶层之间的差异,并研究十年间的变化情况。与英格兰和威尔士的男性相比,20世纪80年代牙医(标准化死亡率66)、医生(69)、配镜师(72)和物理治疗师(79)的死亡率显著较低,而医院搬运工(151)、男护士(118)和救护人员(109)的死亡率则显著较高。医院搬运工的肺癌死亡率(185)是医生(33)和牙医(37)的五倍多。缺血性心脏病死亡率相差两倍,在牙医(60)和医生(70)中最低,在医院搬运工(138)中最高。在这十年间,除医院搬运工、救护人员和勤杂工外,所有群体的肺癌和缺血性心脏病死亡率均有所下降。大多数群体的自杀和肝硬化导致的死亡人数过多。20世纪70年代至80年代,社会阶层I的卫生工作者与社会阶层IV的卫生工作者之间的死亡率差异扩大,且扩大程度大于普通人群。国民保健服务体系(NHS)中一些群体的高死亡率,以及社会阶层之间的差异比普通人群扩大得更多这一事实,表明NHS需要更加关注其自身工作人员的健康。