Tan Ji-ping, Li Nan, Gao Jing, Wang Lu-ning, Zhao Yi-ming, Yu Bao-cheng, Du Wei, Zhang Wen-jun, Cui Lian-qi, Wang Qing-song, Li Jian-jun, Yang Jin-sheng, Yu Jian-min, Xia Xiang-nan, Zhou Pei-yi
Department of Geriatric Neurology, Chinese PLA General Hospital, Beijing, P.R. China.
Research Center of Clinical Epidemiology, Peking University Third Hospital, Beijing, P.R. China.
J Alzheimers Dis. 2015;43(4):1403-12. doi: 10.3233/JAD-141278.
All versions of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) lack population-based data of 80-plus individuals. The norms and cut-off scores for mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and dementia of the MoCA are different among five Chinese versions.
To provide the cut-off scores in detecting MCI and dementia of the Peking Medical Union College Hospital version of the MoCA (MoCA-P).
In a cross-sectional survey, Chinese veterans aged ≥60 years completed the MoCA-P and the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE).
Among 7,445 elderly veterans, 5,085 (68.30%) were aged ≥80 years old, 2,621 (35.20%) had 6 years of education or less, 6,847 (91.97%) were male, and 2,311 (31.04%) and 984 (13.22%) veterans were diagnosed as having MCI and dementia, respectively. Adding two points and one point to the MoCA scores for the primary and middle school groups, respectively, can fully adjust for the notable impact of education but cannot compensate for the effect of age. In the three age groups (60-79, 80-89, and ≥90 years old), the optimal MoCA-P cut-off scores for detecting MCI were ≤25, ≤24, and ≤23, respectively, and for detecting dementia were ≤24, ≤21, and ≤19, respectively, which demonstrated relatively high sensitivities and specificities. The areas under the curves for the MoCA-P for detecting MCI and dementia (0.937 and 0.908, respectively) were greater than those for the MMSE (0.848 and 0.892, respectively).
Compared with the MMSE, the MoCA-P is significantly better for detecting MCI in the elderly, particularly in the oldest old population, and it also displays more effectiveness in detecting dementia.
所有版本的蒙特利尔认知评估量表(MoCA)都缺乏针对80岁及以上人群基于总体人群的数据。MoCA的轻度认知障碍(MCI)和痴呆的常模及截断分数在五个中文版之间存在差异。
提供北京协和医院版MoCA(MoCA-P)在检测MCI和痴呆方面的截断分数。
在一项横断面调查中,年龄≥60岁的中国退伍军人完成了MoCA-P和简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)。
在7445名老年退伍军人中,5085名(68.30%)年龄≥80岁,2621名(35.20%)接受教育年限为6年或以下,6847名(91.97%)为男性,分别有2311名(31.04%)和984名(13.22%)退伍军人被诊断为患有MCI和痴呆。小学组和中学组的MoCA分数分别增加2分和1分,可以充分调整教育程度的显著影响,但无法弥补年龄的影响。在三个年龄组(60-79岁、80-89岁和≥90岁)中,检测MCI的最佳MoCA-P截断分数分别为≤25、≤24和≤23,检测痴呆的最佳截断分数分别为≤24、≤21和≤19,显示出相对较高的敏感性和特异性。MoCA-P检测MCI和痴呆的曲线下面积(分别为0.937和0.908)大于MMSE的曲线下面积(分别为0.848和0.892)。
与MMSE相比,MoCA-P在检测老年人尤其是高龄老人的MCI方面明显更好,在检测痴呆方面也更有效。