Wright Emily M, Fagan Abigail A
School of Criminology and Criminal Justice, University of Nebraska at Omaha.
College of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Florida State University.
Criminology. 2013 May;51(2):217-249. doi: 10.1111/1745-9125.12003.
Although the cycle of violence theory has received empirical support (Widom, 1989a, 1989b), in reality, not all victims of child physical abuse become involved in violence. Therefore, little is known regarding factors that may moderate the relationship between abuse and subsequent violence, particularly contextual circumstances. The current investigation used longitudinal data from 1,372 youth living in 79 neighborhoods who participated in the Project on Human Development in Chicago Neighborhoods (PHDCN), and it employed a multivariate, multilevel Rasch model to explore the degree to which neighborhood disadvantage and cultural norms attenuate or strengthen the abuse-violence relationship. The results indicate that the effect of child physical abuse on violence was weaker in more disadvantaged communities. Neighborhood cultural norms regarding tolerance for youth delinquency and fighting among family and friends did not moderate the child abuse-violence relationship, but each had a direct effect on violence, such that residence in neighborhoods more tolerant of delinquency and fighting increased the propensity for violence. These results suggest that the cycle of violence may be contextualized by neighborhood structural and cultural conditions.
尽管暴力循环理论已得到实证支持(威登,1989a,1989b),但实际上,并非所有受虐儿童都会卷入暴力行为。因此,对于可能缓和虐待与后续暴力行为之间关系的因素,尤其是情境因素,我们了解甚少。当前的调查使用了来自居住在79个社区的1372名青少年的纵向数据,这些青少年参与了芝加哥社区人类发展项目(PHDCN),并采用多元多层次拉施模型来探究社区劣势和文化规范在何种程度上削弱或强化虐待与暴力行为之间的关系。结果表明,在处境更为不利的社区中,儿童身体虐待对暴力行为的影响较弱。关于对青少年犯罪的容忍度以及家人和朋友间打斗的社区文化规范并未缓和虐待儿童与暴力行为之间的关系,但每种规范都对暴力行为有直接影响,即居住在对犯罪和打斗容忍度更高的社区会增加暴力倾向。这些结果表明,暴力循环可能受社区结构和文化条件的影响。