Hammond David, O'Connor Richard J
School of Public Health and Health Systems, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Health Behavior, Roswell Park Cancer Institute, Buffalo, New York.
Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev. 2014 Oct;23(10):2032-40. doi: 10.1158/1055-9965.EPI-13-0957. Epub 2014 Aug 22.
The U.S. FDA has the authority to limit the nicotine content of cigarettes; however, there are concerns that reduced nicotine cigarettes will be smoked more intensely and, therefore, will increase exposure to toxic chemicals in smoke. This study examined changes in consumer behavior and exposure in response to cigarettes with substantially reduced nicotine content.
Seventy-two adult smokers completed an unblinded trial of reduced nicotine cigarettes. Participants completed a 7-day baseline period during which they smoked their usual cigarette brand, followed by consecutive 7-day periods smoking cigarettes with progressively lower nicotine levels (0.6, 0.3, and 0.05 mg emission Quest cigarettes). Nicotine dependence and withdrawal, smoking behavior, and biomarkers of exposure were assessed for each 7-day period.
Significant reductions in nicotine intake were observed between usual brand smoking (∼1.2 mg nicotine) and the 0.3 and 0.05 mg nicotine emission cigarettes, but not the 0.6 mg cigarette. The findings provide little evidence of compensatory smoking of Quest cigarettes, with no increases in exhaled breath carbon monoxide levels, smoking intensity, or levels of 1-hydroxypyrene across study periods. No significant differences were observed for smoking urges or measures of nicotine dependence.
The study adds to the evidence that cigarettes with markedly reduced nicotine content are not associated with increased smoking intensity or exposure to smoke toxicants.
The findings add to the evidence base on reduced nicotine content cigarettes and have the potential to inform FDA policy on nicotine levels.
美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)有权限制香烟中的尼古丁含量;然而,有人担心尼古丁含量降低的香烟会被更用力地吸食,从而增加对烟雾中有毒化学物质的接触。本研究调查了消费者行为的变化以及对尼古丁含量大幅降低的香烟的接触情况。
72名成年吸烟者完成了一项关于尼古丁含量降低的香烟的非盲法试验。参与者先进行了为期7天的基线期,在此期间他们吸食自己常用的香烟品牌,随后是连续的7天周期,分别吸食尼古丁含量逐渐降低的香烟(每支释放0.6毫克、0.3毫克和0.05毫克尼古丁的探索牌香烟)。对每个7天周期评估尼古丁依赖和戒断情况、吸烟行为以及接触生物标志物。
在吸食常用品牌香烟(约1.2毫克尼古丁)与吸食每支释放0.3毫克和0.05毫克尼古丁的香烟之间,观察到尼古丁摄入量显著降低,但与每支释放0.6毫克尼古丁的香烟相比无显著差异。研究结果几乎没有提供证据表明探索牌香烟存在补偿性吸烟现象,在整个研究期间,呼出的一氧化碳水平、吸烟强度或1-羟基芘水平均未增加。在吸烟欲望或尼古丁依赖测量方面未观察到显著差异。
该研究进一步证明,尼古丁含量显著降低的香烟与吸烟强度增加或接触烟雾毒物无关。
这些发现增加了关于尼古丁含量降低的香烟的证据基础,并有可能为FDA关于尼古丁水平的政策提供参考。