Departments of Anatomy and Neurobiology.
Departments of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Economics, and Biomedical Engineering, Washington University in St Louis, St Louis, Missouri 63110
J Neurosci. 2014 Aug 27;34(35):11583-603. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1235-14.2014.
Economic goods may vary on multiple dimensions (determinants). A central conjecture in decision neuroscience is that choices between goods are made by comparing subjective values computed through the integration of all relevant determinants. Previous work identified three groups of neurons in the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) of monkeys engaged in economic choices: (1) offer value cells, which encode the value of individual offers; (2) chosen value cells, which encode the value of the chosen good; and (3) chosen juice cells, which encode the identity of the chosen good. In principle, these populations could be sufficient to generate a decision. Critically, previous work did not assess whether offer value cells (the putative input to the decision) indeed encode subjective values as opposed to physical properties of the goods, and/or whether offer value cells integrate multiple determinants. To address these issues, we recorded from the OFC while monkeys chose between risky outcomes. Confirming previous observations, three populations of neurons encoded the value of individual offers, the value of the chosen option, and the value-independent choice outcome. The activity of both offer value cells and chosen value cells encoded values defined by the integration of juice quantity and probability. Furthermore, both populations reflected the subjective risk attitude of the animals. We also found additional groups of neurons encoding the risk associated with a particular option, the risky nature of the chosen option, and whether the trial outcome was positive or negative. These results provide substantial support for the conjecture described above and for the involvement of OFC in good-based decisions.
经济商品可能在多个维度(决定因素)上有所不同。决策神经科学的一个核心假设是,通过整合所有相关决定因素来计算主观价值,然后在商品之间进行选择。先前的研究在猴子的眶额皮质(OFC)中发现了三组参与经济选择的神经元:(1)出价价值细胞,它编码单个出价的价值;(2)选择价值细胞,它编码所选商品的价值;(3)选择果汁细胞,它编码所选商品的身份。原则上,这些群体足以做出决定。至关重要的是,以前的工作没有评估出价价值细胞(决策的假设输入)是否确实编码主观价值,而不是商品的物理属性,和/或出价价值细胞是否整合了多个决定因素。为了解决这些问题,我们在猴子在风险结果之间进行选择时记录了 OFC 的活动。证实了先前的观察结果,三组神经元编码了单个出价的价值、所选选项的价值和与选择无关的结果的价值。出价价值细胞和选择价值细胞的活动都编码了由果汁数量和概率的整合定义的价值。此外,这两个群体都反映了动物的主观风险态度。我们还发现了编码特定选项相关风险、所选选项的风险性质以及试验结果是正还是负的其他神经元群体。这些结果为上述假设以及 OFC 在基于商品的决策中的参与提供了实质性支持。