Nervo Beatrice, Tocco Claudia, Caprio Enrico, Palestrini Claudia, Rolando Antonio
Department of Life Sciences and Systems Biology, University of Torino, Torino, Italy.
PLoS One. 2014 Sep 17;9(9):e107699. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0107699. eCollection 2014.
Understanding of the role of body mass in structural-functional relationships is pressing, particularly because species losses often occur non-randomly with respect to body size. Our study examined the effects of dung beetle body mass on dung removal at two levels. First, we used the lab experiment to evaluate the efficiency of eight dung beetle species belonging to two functional groups (tunnelers, dwellers) on dung removal. Second, the same species employed in the lab were used in field mesocosms to examine the effects of the two functional groups on dung removal maintaining realistic differences in the total body mass between tunneler and dweller assemblages. Furthermore, the experimental assemblages contained one and four species within each functional group, so the effect of body mass heterogeneity was examined. We used a statistical approach (offset method) which took into account a priori constraints due to the study design allowing us to analyse the effect of larger species in mesocosm style experiments. Body size played a crucial role in dung removal: large beetles were more efficient than small ones and the percentage of removed dung increased with higher body mass heterogeneity. Tunnelers were more efficient than dwellers over both short and long time periods (one month and one year). Significant effects of dwellers were found only after one year. Moreover, our study showed that not including the body mass as an offset in the model resulted in sometimes different results, as the offset expresses dung removal independently of the body mass. This approach confirmed that body size is likely a pivotal factor controlling dung removal efficiency at multiple levels, from single species to overall dung beetle assemblages. Even though other specific traits should be examined, this study has begun to address the consequences of losing individuals with specific traits that are especially sensitive to perturbations.
了解体重在结构-功能关系中的作用迫在眉睫,特别是因为物种丧失往往在体型方面并非随机发生。我们的研究从两个层面考察了蜣螂体重对粪便清除的影响。首先,我们通过实验室实验评估了属于两个功能组(挖掘者、居住者)的八种蜣螂物种在粪便清除方面的效率。其次,将实验室中使用的相同物种用于田间中型生态系统,以研究这两个功能组对粪便清除的影响,同时保持挖掘者和居住者组合在总体重上的实际差异。此外,实验组合在每个功能组内分别包含一个和四个物种,因此考察了体重异质性的影响。我们采用了一种统计方法(偏移法),该方法考虑了由于研究设计产生的先验限制,使我们能够在中型生态系统风格的实验中分析较大物种的影响。体型在粪便清除中起着关键作用:大型甲虫比小型甲虫更有效,并且随着体重异质性的增加,被清除粪便的百分比也会增加。在短期和长期(一个月和一年)内,挖掘者都比居住者更有效。仅在一年后才发现居住者有显著影响。此外,我们的研究表明,在模型中不将体重作为偏移量有时会导致不同的结果,因为偏移量表示独立于体重的粪便清除情况。这种方法证实,体型可能是控制粪便清除效率的一个关键因素,从单个物种到整个蜣螂组合的多个层面都是如此。尽管还应研究其他特定特征,但这项研究已开始探讨失去对干扰特别敏感的具有特定特征个体的后果。