Merlo Gregory, Page Katie, Ratcliffe Julie, Halton Kate, Graves Nicholas
Centre of Research Excellence in Reducing Healthcare Associated Infections (CRE-RHAI), Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation, Queensland University of Technology (QUT), Brisbane, Australia,
Appl Health Econ Health Policy. 2015 Jun;13(3):303-9. doi: 10.1007/s40258-014-0132-7.
Evidence from economic evaluations is often not used to inform healthcare policy despite being well regarded by policy makers and physicians. This article employs the accessibility and acceptability framework to review the barriers to using evidence from economic evaluation in healthcare policy and the strategies used to overcome these barriers. Economic evaluations are often inaccessible to policymakers due to the absence of relevant economic evaluations, the time and cost required to conduct and interpret economic evaluations, and lack of expertise to evaluate quality and interpret results. Consistently reported factors that limit the translation of findings from economic evaluations into healthcare policy include poor quality of research informing economic evaluations, assumptions used in economic modelling, conflicts of interest, difficulties in transferring resources between sectors, negative attitudes to healthcare rationing, and the absence of equity considerations. Strategies to overcome these barriers have been suggested in the literature, including training, structured abstract databases, rapid evaluation, reporting checklists for journals, and considering factors other than cost effectiveness in economic evaluations, such as equity or budget impact. The factors that prevent or encourage decision makers to use evidence from economic evaluations have been identified, but the relative importance of these factors to decision makers is uncertain.
尽管经济评估证据受到政策制定者和医生的高度重视,但在为医疗政策提供信息时,这些证据往往未被采用。本文运用可及性和可接受性框架,审视在医疗政策中使用经济评估证据的障碍以及为克服这些障碍所采用的策略。由于缺乏相关经济评估、进行和解读经济评估所需的时间与成本,以及评估质量和解读结果的专业知识匮乏,政策制定者往往难以获取经济评估。一直以来,限制将经济评估结果转化为医疗政策的因素包括:为经济评估提供信息的研究质量不佳、经济模型中使用的假设、利益冲突、不同部门之间转移资源的困难、对医疗资源配给的负面态度,以及缺乏公平性考量。文献中已提出克服这些障碍的策略,包括培训、结构化摘要数据库、快速评估、期刊报告清单,以及在经济评估中考虑除成本效益之外的其他因素,如公平性或预算影响。已确定了阻碍或鼓励决策者使用经济评估证据的因素,但这些因素对决策者的相对重要性尚不确定。