O'Toole Mia S, Mennin Douglas S, Hougaard Esben, Zachariae Robert, Rosenberg Nicole K
Department of Psychology and Behavioral Sciences, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
Department of Psychology, Hunter College, City University of New York, New York City, NY, USA.
Clin Psychol Psychother. 2015 Nov-Dec;22(6):667-76. doi: 10.1002/cpp.1926. Epub 2014 Oct 13.
The objective of the study was to investigate variables, derived from both cognitive and emotion regulation conceptualizations of social anxiety disorder (SAD), as possible change processes in cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) for SAD. Several proposed change processes were investigated: estimated probability, estimated cost, safety behaviours, acceptance of emotions, cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression. Participants were 50 patients with SAD, receiving a standard manualized CBT program, conducted in groups or individually. All variables were measured pre-therapy, mid-therapy and post-therapy. Lower level mediation models revealed that while a change in most process measures significantly predicted clinical improvement, only changes in estimated probability and cost and acceptance of emotions showed significant indirect effects of CBT for SAD. The results are in accordance with previous studies supporting the mediating role of changes in cognitive distortions in CBT for SAD. In addition, acceptance of emotions may also be a critical component to clinical improvement in SAD during CBT, although more research is needed on which elements of acceptance are most helpful for individuals with SAD. The study's lack of a control condition limits any conclusion regarding the specificity of the findings to CBT.
Change in estimated probability and cost, and acceptance of emotions showed an indirect effect of CBT for SAD. Cognitive distortions appear relevant to target with cognitive restructuring techniques. Finding acceptance to have an indirect effect could be interpreted as support for contemporary CBT approaches that include acceptance-based strategies.
本研究的目的是调查源自社交焦虑障碍(SAD)认知和情绪调节概念化的变量,作为SAD认知行为疗法(CBT)中可能的改变过程。研究了几个提出的改变过程:估计概率、估计成本、安全行为、情绪接纳、认知重评和表达抑制。参与者为50名SAD患者,接受标准的手册化CBT项目,以小组或个体形式进行。所有变量在治疗前、治疗中期和治疗后进行测量。较低层次的中介模型显示,虽然大多数过程测量的变化显著预测了临床改善,但只有估计概率、成本和情绪接纳的变化显示出CBT对SAD的显著间接效应。结果与先前支持认知扭曲变化在SAD的CBT中起中介作用的研究一致。此外,情绪接纳也可能是CBT期间SAD临床改善的关键组成部分,尽管需要更多研究来确定接纳的哪些要素对SAD个体最有帮助。该研究缺乏对照条件限制了关于这些发现对CBT特异性的任何结论。
估计概率、成本的变化以及情绪接纳显示出CBT对SAD的间接效应。认知扭曲似乎与认知重构技术的目标相关。发现接纳有间接效应可以解释为对包括基于接纳策略的当代CBT方法的支持。