Department of Psychiatry, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2014 Jul;56(3):301-4. doi: 10.4103/0019-5545.120560.
Psychiatric nosology is required for communication among clinicians and researchers, understanding etiology, testing treatment efficacy, knowing the prevalence of the problems and disorders, healthcare planning, organizing the services, and reimbursement purposes. Many approaches have been used for psychiatric nosology, including categorical, dimensional, hybrid, and etiological. The categorical approach considers illness as being either present or absent, and similarity with prototypical description of a disorder is taken as a marker for the disorder. The dimensional approach regards that symptoms of disorder exist on a continuum from normal to severely ill. The hybrid approach combines categorical and dimensional approaches, with categorical diagnosis for broad diagnostic group and dimensional indicator for severity. The etiological approach tends to find "reason" for the set of symptoms, which could be biological, psychological, or social. In this article, certain critical issues about the different nosological approaches are discussed. Hybrid approach currently seems to be the most preferred for widespread usage. In conclusion, psychiatric nosology needs to evolve through epistemic iteration leading to successive changes and devising a more refined and useful system with time.
精神病学的分类学对于临床医生和研究人员之间的交流、病因理解、治疗效果测试、了解问题和障碍的流行程度、医疗保健规划、服务组织和报销目的是必要的。已经使用了许多方法来进行精神病学的分类学,包括分类、维度、混合和病因。分类方法认为疾病要么存在,要么不存在,并且与疾病的典型描述的相似性被视为疾病的标志物。维度方法认为,疾病的症状存在于从正常到严重的连续体上。混合方法结合了分类和维度方法,使用分类诊断进行广泛的诊断组分类,使用维度指标进行严重程度分类。病因方法倾向于为一组症状找到“原因”,这些原因可能是生物的、心理的或社会的。本文讨论了不同分类方法的某些关键问题。混合方法目前似乎是最受欢迎的广泛应用方法。总之,精神病学的分类学需要通过认识迭代来发展,从而导致连续的变化,并随着时间的推移设计出一个更精细和有用的系统。