Balci Ali, Basara Işıl, Çekdemir Ertuğ Yasin, Tetik Filiz, Aktaş Gülşah, Acarer Aslı, Özaksoy Dinç
Department of Radiology, Dokuz Eylul University, Faculty of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey,
Emerg Radiol. 2015 Jun;22(3):251-6. doi: 10.1007/s10140-014-1278-1. Epub 2014 Oct 18.
The aims of this study are to evaluate diagnostic performance of conventional radiographs for wrist fractures using multidetector computerized tomography (MDCT) as a reference standard, to determine prevalence, demographic risk factors including age and sex, and associations among various wrist fractures. A retrospective study was performed, finding a total 455 patients (457 wrists) who had wrist trauma and who had undergone a radiography and subsequent MDCT examination during a 45-month period. The MDCT and radiographs of the patients were reviewed by two radiologists, and a consensus was obtained for the presence of fracture. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) of radiographs were calculated using MDCT findings as reference standard. The correlation of both age and sex between the presence of fracture was also analyzed. Of the 455 patients, 223 (49.0 %) had one or more fractures in wrist. A total of 302 (160 patients had one, 50 had two, 10 had three, and 3 had four) fractures were diagnosed in the wrist region. In 457 wrists, MDCT revealed 128 occult fractures missed by radiography. The overall sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV of radiography for the detection of all wrist fractures were 57.8, 99.5, 87.4, and 97.4 %, respectively. The sensitivities of radiography ranged 0-41.2 % for other carpal bone except scaphoid (66 %) fractures and 66.7-80 % for the proximal metacarpus, distal ulna, and radius fractures. Wrist fractures appear to be overlooked on radiography. Further imaging should be warranted for patients who are clinically suspicious for wrist fracture in emergency rooms.
本研究的目的是使用多排螺旋计算机断层扫描(MDCT)作为参考标准,评估传统X线片对腕部骨折的诊断性能,确定患病率、包括年龄和性别的人口统计学风险因素,以及各种腕部骨折之间的关联。进行了一项回顾性研究,共纳入455例(457侧腕部)有腕部外伤且在45个月期间接受过X线检查及后续MDCT检查的患者。两名放射科医生对患者的MDCT和X线片进行了复查,并就骨折的存在达成了共识。以MDCT检查结果作为参考标准,计算X线片的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV)。还分析了骨折存在与年龄和性别的相关性。455例患者中,223例(49.0%)腕部有一处或多处骨折。腕部区域共诊断出302处骨折(160例患者有一处骨折,50例有两处骨折,10例有三处骨折,3例有四处骨折)。在457侧腕部中,MDCT发现了128处X线片漏诊的隐匿性骨折。X线片检测所有腕部骨折的总体敏感性、特异性、PPV和NPV分别为57.8%、99.5%、87.4%和97.4%。除舟骨骨折(66%)外,其他腕骨骨折X线片的敏感性范围为0 - 41.2%,掌骨近端、尺骨远端和桡骨骨折的敏感性为66.7% - 80%。腕部骨折在X线片上似乎容易被漏诊。对于急诊室中临床怀疑有腕部骨折的患者,应进行进一步的影像学检查。