Schünemann H, Jourdain M
Onkologische Klinik Bad Trissl.
Dtsch Med Wochenschr. 1989 Jan 6;114(1):3-8. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1066542.
In 1987/88 a prospective study was undertaken of 750 patients with postoperative carcinoma of the breast but no evidence as yet of skeletal metastases. A thorough history regarding pain was taken with pre-set questions and an exact clinical examination conducted to reveal any skeletal pain. Subsequently whole-body skeletal scanning was performed, plus additional X-ray films, determination of tumour markers CA-15-3 and CEA, and further tests as indicated. Clinical and imaging results agreed in 649 patients. In 70 patients the clinical suspicion or questionable finding of metastases was not confirmed by radiology or a scan. Bone metastases would have been missed in only 14 patients (1.9%) without a skeletal scan. Eleven of these 14 patients were in high-risk groups (negative hormone receptor status; axillary lymph node metastases). Skeletal metastases were undiscovered in only three of the 750 patients (0.4%). It is thus sufficient to limit skeletal scans to high-risk groups, as long as a careful history of pain is taken and a thorough clinical examination conducted.
1987/88年,对750例乳腺癌术后患者进行了一项前瞻性研究,这些患者当时尚无骨骼转移的证据。通过预设问题详细询问了疼痛病史,并进行了精确的临床检查以发现任何骨骼疼痛。随后进行了全身骨骼扫描,外加额外的X光片、肿瘤标志物CA-15-3和癌胚抗原(CEA)的测定以及其他指示性检查。649例患者的临床和影像学结果一致。70例患者的临床转移疑似或可疑发现未被放射学或扫描证实。如果没有骨骼扫描,仅14例患者(1.9%)的骨转移会被漏诊。这14例患者中有11例属于高危组(激素受体状态阴性;腋窝淋巴结转移)。750例患者中仅3例(0.4%)未发现骨骼转移。因此,只要仔细询问疼痛病史并进行全面的临床检查,将骨骼扫描限制在高危组就足够了。