Youssef Nagy A, McCall W Vaughn
Department of Psychiatry and Health Behavior, The Medical College of Georgia at Georgia Regents University, Charlie Norwood VA Medical Center, Augusta, GA, USA. E-mail:
Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2014 Nov;26(4):288-96.
One-third of patients who suffer from depression are resistant to conventional treatments. An acute course of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) can lead to remission of depressive symptoms in a substantial portion of the treatment-resistant patients. However, prevention of relapse with depressive symptoms after the index course of ECT can be challenging. We review pertinent studies on the topic and analyze the best strategies to avoid relapse and recurrence of depressive symptoms.
We performed a systematic literature review of PubMed through April 2014 for clinical trials published in English to determine if continuation ECT (C-ECT), continuation medication, continuation psychotherapy, or combinations of these are the best strategy to avoid relapse and recurrence of depressive symptoms after an acute course of ECT. Clinical trials comparing ≥2 of the above strategies were included in the review.
Although there are few rigorous randomized clinical trials in this area, most studies suggest that combined C-ECT and continuation pharmacotherapy are the most effective strategy in relapse prevention.
C-ECT and continuation pharmacotherapy may be more effective than either alone for preventing relapse. However, more definitive randomized clinical trials are needed.
三分之一的抑郁症患者对传统治疗有抵抗性。急性电休克治疗(ECT)疗程可使相当一部分难治性患者的抑郁症状得到缓解。然而,在ECT索引疗程后预防抑郁症状复发可能具有挑战性。我们回顾了该主题的相关研究,并分析了避免抑郁症状复发和再发的最佳策略。
我们对截至2014年4月的PubMed进行了系统的文献综述,以查找用英文发表的临床试验,确定继续ECT(C-ECT)、继续药物治疗、继续心理治疗或这些方法的组合是否是在急性ECT疗程后避免抑郁症状复发和再发的最佳策略。比较上述≥2种策略的临床试验纳入了该综述。
尽管该领域严格的随机临床试验较少,但大多数研究表明,联合C-ECT和继续药物治疗是预防复发最有效的策略。
C-ECT和继续药物治疗在预防复发方面可能比单独使用任一种方法更有效。然而,需要更多确定性的随机临床试验。