Ferreira Padilla Guillermo, Ferrández Antón Teresa, Baleriola Júlvez José, Almeida Cabrera Rut
Grupo de Investigación ComunVista, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Católica de Valencia, Valencia, España (www.laboratoriodecomunicacion.wordpress.com).
Grupo de Investigación ComunVista, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Católica de Valencia, Valencia, España (www.laboratoriodecomunicacion.wordpress.com).
Aten Primaria. 2015 Aug-Sep;47(7):399-410. doi: 10.1016/j.aprim.2014.09.007. Epub 2014 Nov 27.
Analyse the currently situation of teaching in communication skills in the Spanish Medical Schools (MS) and the grade of implementation from the recommended by the National Agency of Evaluation of the Quality and Accreditation.
Descriptive-comparative, transversal and quantitative-qualitative study.
University teaching field.
The whole population of MS in Spain.
teaching during the academic year 2013-2014 the Degree in Medicine homologated by the National Agency of Evaluation of the Quality and Accreditation and offering information of their educational plans and teaching guides (online, telephonic or e-mail).
Forty-two MS: 10 privates and 32 publics. Thirty MS (71.43%) presented at least one course of communication skills. The 78.12% of the public MS contained this kind of teaching as an entire course versus the 50.00% of the private MS. The national average by MS was 2.77 (σ=2.41), lower than the 5.0 credits recommended by the the National Agency of Evaluation of the Quality and Accreditation (relevant difference: d=1.63>>0,8). The 63.63% contained this teaching over the second cycle (mode: second degree).
The course loads in terms of credits destined to this skills has increased considerably from 1990 to 2014 (d= 1,43>>0,8). However, it has not been completely established yet the recommendations about this aspect in most of the Spanish MS. The public universities seem to be more aware of this teaching. Furthermore, it would be interesting strengthen this skills in the sixth grade.
分析西班牙医学院校(MS)沟通技能教学的现状以及国家质量评估与认证机构所推荐内容的实施程度。
描述性比较、横向以及定量定性研究。
大学教学领域。
西班牙所有医学院校。
在2013 - 2014学年教授经国家质量评估与认证机构认可的医学学位课程,并提供其教育计划和教学指南信息(在线、电话或电子邮件)。
1)沟通技能课程的存在情况;2)教学类型;3)课程形式;4)学分;5)时长;6)等级。使用描述性参数和科恩系数(d)进行分析。
42所医学院校,其中10所私立,32所公立。30所医学院校(71.43%)开设了至少一门沟通技能课程。公立医学院校中有78.12%将此类教学作为一门完整课程,而私立医学院校中这一比例为50.00%。各医学院校的全国平均学分为2.77(标准差 = 2.41),低于国家质量评估与认证机构推荐的5.0学分(显著差异:d = 1.63 >> 0.8)。63.63%的课程在第二阶段(模式:第二学位)开展此类教学。
从1990年到2014年,用于此类技能教学的学分课程量有了显著增加(d = 1.43 >> 0.8)。然而,在大多数西班牙医学院校中,关于这方面的建议尚未完全确立。公立大学似乎对此类教学更为重视。此外,在六年级加强此类技能教学会很有意义。