Jang Sung-In, Cho Kyoung-Hee, Kim Sun Jung, Lee Kwang-Sig, Park Eun-Cheol
Department of Preventive Medicine and Institute of Health Services Research, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Cancer Res Treat. 2015 Apr;47(2):149-57. doi: 10.4143/crt.2013.167. Epub 2014 Sep 11.
The aim of study was to provide suggestions for prioritizing research in effort to reduce cancer burden in Korea based on a comprehensive analysis of cancer burden and Delphi consensus among cancer experts.
Twenty research plans covering 10 topics were selected based on an assessment of the literature, and e-mail surveys were analyzed using a two-round modified Delphi method. Thirty-four out of 79 experts were selected from four organizations to participate in round one, and 21 experts among them had completed round two. Each item had two questions; one regarding the agreement of the topic as a priority item to reduce cancer burden, and the other about the importance of the item on a nine-point scale. A consensus was defined to be an average lower coefficient of variation with less than 30% in importance.
Seven plans that satisfied the three criteria were selected as priority research plans for reducing cancer burden. These plans are "research into advanced clinical guidelines for thyroid cancer given the current issue with over-diagnosis," "research into smoking management plans through price and non-price cigarette policy initiatives," "research into ways to measure the quality of cancer care," "research on policy development to expand hospice care," "research into the spread and management of Helicobacter pylori," "research on palliative care in a clinical setting," and "research into alternative mammography methods to increase the accuracy of breast cancer screenings."
The seven plans identified in this study should be prioritized to reduce the burden of cancer in Korea. We suggest that policy makers and administrators study and invest significant effort in these plans.
本研究旨在通过对癌症负担进行全面分析以及癌症专家的德尔菲共识,为韩国确定降低癌症负担的优先研究方向提供建议。
基于文献评估选出涵盖10个主题的20项研究计划,并采用两轮改进的德尔菲方法对电子邮件调查进行分析。从四个组织中选出79名专家中的34名参与第一轮调查,其中21名专家完成了第二轮调查。每个项目有两个问题:一个是关于该主题作为降低癌症负担的优先项目的认可度,另一个是关于该项目在九点量表上的重要性。共识被定义为重要性方面变异系数平均值较低且低于30%。
选出了符合三项标准的七项计划作为降低癌症负担的优先研究计划。这些计划包括“鉴于当前过度诊断问题对甲状腺癌高级临床指南的研究”“通过价格和非价格卷烟政策举措对吸烟管理计划的研究”“癌症护理质量衡量方法研究”“扩大临终关怀护理的政策制定研究”“幽门螺杆菌传播与管理研究”“临床环境下的姑息治疗研究 ”以及“提高乳腺癌筛查准确性的替代乳房X线摄影方法研究”。
本研究确定的七项计划应作为韩国降低癌症负担的优先事项。我们建议政策制定者和管理人员对这些计划进行研究并投入大量精力。