Baker Carmen S, Cinelli Michael E
Department of Kinesiology and Physical Education, Wilfrid Laurier University, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Physiol Rep. 2014 Dec 24;2(12). doi: 10.14814/phy2.12252. Print 2014 Dec 1.
Current protocols for returning athletes to play (RTP) center around resolution of physical symptoms of concussion. However, recent research has identified that balance and cognitive deficits persist beyond physical symptom recovery. Protocols that involve testing dynamic balance and visuomotor integration have been recommended as potential tools for better understanding of length of impairment following concussion. A dynamic, visuomotor paradigm was undertaken in the current study to assess decision making in athletes who had sustained a concussion >30 days before study participation and had been cleared to RTP (N = 10). Two obstacles created a gap that varied between 0.6 and 1.8× participants' individual shoulder width in open space. Participants made decisions to navigate through or deviate around the gap created by the two obstacles. The results revealed that previously concussed athletes were highly variable in their decision making and demonstrated variable Medial-Lateral (ML) center of mass (COM) control when approaching the obstacles, when compared with nonconcussed, age-matched controls. As such, they showed poor visuomotor control and decision making, as well as poor dynamic stability compared to controls. Visuomotor deficits were persistent in the sample of previously concussed individuals, well beyond deficits identified by current RTP standards. This study suggests that dynamic, visuomotor integration tasks may be of benefit to increase rigor in RTP protocols and increase safety of athletes returning to sport.
目前运动员重返赛场(RTP)的方案主要围绕脑震荡身体症状的解决。然而,最近的研究发现,在身体症状恢复后,平衡和认知缺陷仍然存在。建议采用涉及测试动态平衡和视觉运动整合的方案,作为更好地了解脑震荡后损伤持续时间的潜在工具。在本研究中采用了一种动态视觉运动范式,以评估在研究参与前30天以上遭受脑震荡且已被批准重返赛场的运动员(N = 10)的决策能力。在开放空间中,两个障碍物形成了一个宽度在参与者个人肩宽的0.6至1.8倍之间变化的间隙。参与者决定是穿过还是绕过由两个障碍物形成的间隙。结果显示,与未受过脑震荡的年龄匹配对照组相比,先前受过脑震荡的运动员在决策过程中差异很大,并且在接近障碍物时表现出不同的内侧-外侧(ML)质心(COM)控制。因此,与对照组相比,他们表现出较差的视觉运动控制和决策能力,以及较差的动态稳定性。在先前受过脑震荡的个体样本中,视觉运动缺陷持续存在,远远超过当前RTP标准所确定的缺陷。这项研究表明,动态视觉运动整合任务可能有助于提高RTP方案的严格性,并提高运动员重返运动的安全性。