Sullivan Maria A, Bisaga Adam, Glass Andrew, Mishlen Kaitlyn, Pavlicova Martina, Carpenter Kenneth M, Mariani John J, Levin Frances R, Nunes Edward V
Columbia University and the New York State Psychiatric Institute, 1051 Riverside Drive, Unit 120, New York, NY 10032, United States.
Columbia University, 722 W. 168th Street, MSPH Box 12, New York, NY 10032, United States.
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2015 Feb 1;147:122-9. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2014.11.028. Epub 2014 Dec 9.
Adherence to oral naltrexone has been poor and can be improved somewhat with behavioral therapy. We compared behavioral naltrexone therapy (BNT) to compliance enhancement (CE) and tested efficacy of single-dose injection naltrexone (XR-NTX; 384 mg) with behavioral therapies at further improving adherence to oral naltrexone.
A 24-week, randomized, placebo-controlled trial (n=125) compared four treatment conditions following inpatient detoxification and oral naltrexone induction: (1) BNT+XR-NTX; (2) BNT+placebo injection; (3) CE+XR-NTX; and (4) CE+placebo injection. All participants were maintained on oral naltrexone throughout the trial. Primary outcome was retention in treatment.
Of 89 randomized participants, 78.7% (70/89) completed 4 weeks, 58.2% (54/89) completed 8 weeks, 47.2% (42/89) completed 12 weeks, and 25.8% (23/89) completed 24 weeks. A Cox proportional hazards regression modeled time to dropout as a function of treatment condition, baseline opioid dependence severity (bags per day of heroin use), and their interaction. Interaction of conditions by baseline severity was significant (X3(2)=9.19, p=0.027). For low-severity patients (≤ 6 bags/day), retention was highest in the BNT-XR-NTX group (60% at 6 months), as hypothesized. For high-severity (>6 bags/day) patients, BNT-XR-NTX did not perform as well, due to high early attrition.
For low-severity heroin users, single-dose XR-NTX improved long-term treatment retention when combined with behavioral therapy. In higher-severity opioid-dependent patients, XR-NTX was less helpful, perhaps because, combined with oral naltrexone, it produced higher blood levels and more withdrawal discomfort. When cost considerations recommend oral naltrexone following XR-NTX, the latter should be phased in slowly.
口服纳曲酮的依从性一直较差,行为疗法可在一定程度上改善这种情况。我们将行为纳曲酮疗法(BNT)与依从性增强疗法(CE)进行了比较,并测试了单剂量注射用纳曲酮(长效释放型纳曲酮,XR-NTX;384毫克)联合行为疗法在进一步提高口服纳曲酮依从性方面的疗效。
一项为期24周的随机、安慰剂对照试验(n = 125)比较了住院戒毒及口服纳曲酮诱导治疗后的四种治疗方案:(1)BNT + XR-NTX;(2)BNT + 安慰剂注射;(3)CE + XR-NTX;(4)CE + 安慰剂注射。在整个试验过程中,所有参与者均持续接受口服纳曲酮治疗。主要结局指标为治疗保留率。
在89名随机分组的参与者中,78.7%(70/89)完成了4周治疗,58.2%(54/89)完成了8周治疗,47.2%(42/89)完成了12周治疗,25.8%(23/89)完成了24周治疗。Cox比例风险回归模型将退出治疗时间作为治疗方案、基线阿片类药物依赖严重程度(每日海洛因使用量)及其交互作用的函数进行建模。治疗方案与基线严重程度的交互作用显著(X3(2)=9.19,p = 0.027)。正如所假设的,对于低严重程度(≤6袋/天)的患者,BNT-XR-NTX组的治疗保留率最高(6个月时为60%)。对于高严重程度(>6袋/天)的患者,由于早期脱落率较高,BNT-XR-NTX的效果不佳。
对于低严重程度的海洛因使用者,单剂量XR-NTX联合行为疗法可提高长期治疗保留率。在高严重程度的阿片类药物依赖患者中,XR-NTX的帮助较小,可能是因为与口服纳曲酮联合使用时,它会使血药浓度升高,戒断不适症状更明显。当出于成本考虑在XR-NTX后推荐使用口服纳曲酮时,应缓慢引入后者。