Nesse Randolph M, Stearns Stephen C
The University of Michigan.
Yale University.
Evol Appl. 2008 Feb;1(1):28-48. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-4571.2007.00006.x.
Evolutionary biology is an essential basic science for medicine, but few doctors and medical researchers are familiar with its most relevant principles. Most medical schools have geneticists who understand evolution, but few have even one evolutionary biologist to suggest other possible applications. The canyon between evolutionary biology and medicine is wide. The question is whether they offer each other enough to make bridge building worthwhile. What benefits could be expected if evolution were brought fully to bear on the problems of medicine? How would studying medical problems advance evolutionary research? Do doctors need to learn evolution, or is it valuable mainly for researchers? What practical steps will promote the application of evolutionary biology in the areas of medicine where it offers the most? To address these questions, we review current and potential applications of evolutionary biology to medicine and public health. Some evolutionary technologies, such as population genetics, serial transfer production of live vaccines, and phylogenetic analysis, have been widely applied. Other areas, such as infectious disease and aging research, illustrate the dramatic recent progress made possible by evolutionary insights. In still other areas, such as epidemiology, psychiatry, and understanding the regulation of bodily defenses, applying evolutionary principles remains an open opportunity. In addition to the utility of specific applications, an evolutionary perspective fundamentally challenges the prevalent but fundamentally incorrect metaphor of the body as a machine designed by an engineer. Bodies are vulnerable to disease - and remarkably resilient - precisely because they are not machines built from a plan. They are, instead, bundles of compromises shaped by natural selection in small increments to maximize reproduction, not health. Understanding the body as a product of natural selection, not design, offers new research questions and a framework for making medical education more coherent. We conclude with recommendations for actions that would better connect evolutionary biology and medicine in ways that will benefit public health. It is our hope that faculty and students will send this article to their undergraduate and medical school Deans, and that this will initiate discussions about the gap, the great opportunity, and action plans to bring the full power of evolutionary biology to bear on human health problems.
进化生物学是医学必不可少的基础科学,但很少有医生和医学研究人员熟悉其最相关的原理。大多数医学院校都有理解进化的遗传学家,但很少有医学院甚至有一位进化生物学家来提出其他可能的应用。进化生物学与医学之间的鸿沟很宽。问题在于它们是否能为彼此提供足够的东西,使搭建桥梁变得值得。如果将进化充分应用于医学问题,能预期带来哪些益处?研究医学问题将如何推动进化研究?医生需要学习进化吗,还是它主要对研究人员有价值?哪些实际步骤将促进进化生物学在其能提供最大价值的医学领域的应用?为解决这些问题,我们回顾了进化生物学在医学和公共卫生领域的当前及潜在应用。一些进化技术,如群体遗传学、活疫苗的连续传代生产以及系统发育分析,已经得到广泛应用。其他领域,如传染病和衰老研究,展示了进化见解近期所带来的巨大进展。在另外一些领域,如流行病学、精神病学以及理解身体防御的调节,应用进化原理仍是一个有待开发的机会。除了特定应用的实用性之外,进化视角从根本上挑战了将身体比作由工程师设计的机器这一普遍但根本错误的隐喻。身体容易患病——同时又具有显著的复原力——恰恰是因为它们不是按照设计图构建的机器。相反,它们是一系列妥协的集合,通过自然选择以小幅度逐步塑造而成,以最大化繁殖而非健康。将身体理解为自然选择而非设计的产物,提出了新的研究问题,并为使医学教育更具连贯性提供了一个框架。我们最后提出了一些行动建议,这些建议将以有益于公共卫生的方式更好地将进化生物学与医学联系起来。我们希望教师和学生将本文发送给他们所在本科院校和医学院的院长,并且这将引发关于这一差距、巨大机遇以及将进化生物学的全部力量应用于人类健康问题的行动计划的讨论。