Nixon Laura, Mejia Pamela, Dorfman Lori, Cheyne Andrew, Young Sandra, Friedman Lissy C, Gottlieb Mark A, Wooten Heather
Laura Nixon, Pamela Mejia, Lori Dorfman, Andrew Cheyne, and Sandra Young are with Berkeley Media Studies Group, Public Health Institute, Berkeley, CA. Lissy C. Friedman and Mark A. Gottlieb are with the Public Health Advocacy Institute, Boston, MA. Heather Wooten is with ChangeLab Solutions, Oakland, CA.
Am J Public Health. 2015 Mar;105(3):490-6. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2014.302368. Epub 2015 Jan 20.
Zoning and other land-use policies are a promising but controversial strategy to improve community food environments. To understand how these policies are debated, we searched existing databases and the Internet and analyzed news coverage and legal documentation of efforts to restrict fast-food restaurants in 77 US communities in 2001 to 2013. Policies intended to improve community health were most often proposed in urban, racially diverse communities; policies proposed in small towns or majority-White communities aimed to protect community aesthetics or local businesses. Health-focused policies were subject to more criticism than other policies and were generally less successful. Our findings could inform the work of advocates interested in employing land-use policies to improve the food environment in their own communities.
分区规划及其他土地使用政策是改善社区食品环境的一项前景良好但颇具争议的策略。为了解这些政策是如何进行辩论的,我们搜索了现有数据库和互联网,并分析了2001年至2013年期间美国77个社区限制快餐店相关举措的新闻报道和法律文件。旨在改善社区健康的政策最常出现在城市、种族多元化的社区;而在小镇或白人占多数的社区所提出的政策则旨在保护社区美观或当地企业。以健康为重点的政策比其他政策受到更多批评,并且总体上不太成功。我们的研究结果可为有意运用土地使用政策改善其所在社区食品环境的倡导者的工作提供参考。