Obaldia Nicanor
Department of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Instituto Conmemorativo Gorgas de Estudios de la Salud, Panama, Panama.
Malar J. 2015 Jan 21;14:14. doi: 10.1186/s12936-014-0529-7.
Identification of risk factors is important for the establishment of malaria elimination programmes tailored to specific regions. Type of house construction had been associated with increasing risk of acquiring malaria. This study aimed at establishing the association between determinants of low socio-economic status (SES) and type of house construction with the likelihood of living in a Plasmodium vivax malarious corregimiento (smallest political division) in Panama during 2009-2012.
To determine the association between type-2 houses (build with deciduous materials) and other determinants of low SES, with living in a malarious corregimiento, this study analyzed demographic and housing census data (2010), and malaria incidence aggregated at the corregimiento level (2009-2012), using a Spearman's non-parametric correlation test to explore for associations, followed by a case-control study and a reduced multivariate logistic regression approach for confirmation.
A descriptive temporal and spatial analysis indicated that P. vivax in Panama was associated with Amerindian reservations. Moreover, this study demonstrated that a strong correlation (deleterious effect) existed between living in a malarious corregimiento and being exposed to a type-2 house (OR = > 1.0) (p < 0.001), while, it showed an inverse correlation for exposure to type-1 houses (protective effect) (build with permanent materials) (OR = < 1.0) (p < 0.001). In the same way, a significant association between exposure to type-2 houses and the outcome of living in a malarious corregimiento was found using a case-control study approach (Chi(2) test = p < 0.001), that was confirmed applying a reduced multivariate logistic regression fitted model.
This study demonstrated that living in a P. vivax malarious corregimiento in Panama during 2009-2012 was strongly correlated with those corregimientos having a high proportion of type-2 houses. A multivariate logistic regression approach at the house and corregimiento level indicated a strong association of type-2 houses, dirt floors and illiteracy with the likelihood of living in a malarious corregimiento. It is expected that these findings will help implement a multi-sectorial approach for the elimination of malaria in poor areas of Panama where malaria is endemic, which emphasizes house improvements such as mosquito-proofing and socio-economic development.
识别风险因素对于制定适合特定地区的疟疾消除计划至关重要。房屋建造类型与感染疟疾风险的增加有关。本研究旨在确定2009 - 2012年期间巴拿马低社会经济地位(SES)的决定因素和房屋建造类型与生活在间日疟原虫疟疾流行的行政区(最小政治分区)可能性之间的关联。
为了确定2类房屋(用落叶材料建造)和其他低SES决定因素与生活在疟疾流行行政区之间的关联,本研究分析了人口和住房普查数据(2010年)以及行政区层面汇总的疟疾发病率(2009 - 2012年),使用Spearman非参数相关检验探索关联,随后进行病例对照研究和简化多元逻辑回归方法进行确认。
描述性的时间和空间分析表明,巴拿马的间日疟原虫与美洲印第安人保留地有关。此外,本研究表明,生活在疟疾流行的行政区与暴露于2类房屋之间存在强相关性(有害效应)(OR = > 1.0)(p < 0.001),而对于暴露于1类房屋(用永久性材料建造)则显示出负相关性(保护效应)(OR = < 1.0)(p < 0.001)。同样,使用病例对照研究方法发现暴露于2类房屋与生活在疟疾流行行政区的结果之间存在显著关联(卡方检验 = p < 0.001),这通过应用简化多元逻辑回归拟合模型得到了证实。
本研究表明,2009 - 2012年期间生活在巴拿马间日疟原虫疟疾流行的行政区与2类房屋比例高的行政区密切相关。在房屋和行政区层面的多元逻辑回归方法表明,2类房屋、泥土地面和文盲与生活在疟疾流行行政区可能性之间存在强关联。预计这些发现将有助于在巴拿马疟疾流行的贫困地区实施多部门疟疾消除方法,该方法强调房屋改善,如防蚊和社会经济发展。