Chiolero Arnaud, Paccaud Fred, Aujesky Drahomir, Santschi Valérie, Rodondi Nicolas
Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine (IUMSP), Lausanne University Hospital, Switzerland.
Department of General Internal Medicine, Bern University Hospital, Switzerland.
Swiss Med Wkly. 2015 Jan 22;145:w14060. doi: 10.4414/smw.2015.14060. eCollection 2015.
Overdiagnosis is the diagnosis of an abnormality that is not associated with a substantial health hazard and that patients have no benefit to be aware of. It is neither a misdiagnosis (diagnostic error), nor a false positive result (positive test in the absence of a real abnormality). It mainly results from screening, use of increasingly sensitive diagnostic tests, incidental findings on routine examinations, and widening diagnostic criteria to define a condition requiring an intervention. The blurring boundaries between risk and disease, physicians' fear of missing a diagnosis and patients' need for reassurance are further causes of overdiagnosis. Overdiagnosis often implies procedures to confirm or exclude the presence of the condition and is by definition associated with useless treatments and interventions, generating harm and costs without any benefit. Overdiagnosis also diverts healthcare professionals from caring about other health issues. Preventing overdiagnosis requires increasing awareness of healthcare professionals and patients about its occurrence, the avoidance of unnecessary and untargeted diagnostic tests, and the avoidance of screening without demonstrated benefits. Furthermore, accounting systematically for the harms and benefits of screening and diagnostic tests and determining risk factor thresholds based on the expected absolute risk reduction would also help prevent overdiagnosis.
过度诊断是指对一种与重大健康危害无关且患者知晓后并无益处的异常情况进行诊断。它既不是误诊(诊断错误),也不是假阳性结果(在没有真正异常的情况下检测呈阳性)。过度诊断主要源于筛查、使用越来越敏感的诊断测试、常规检查中的偶然发现以及扩大用于定义需要干预的病症的诊断标准。风险与疾病之间界限的模糊、医生对漏诊的恐惧以及患者对安心的需求是过度诊断的进一步原因。过度诊断通常意味着进行程序以确认或排除病症的存在,并且根据定义与无用的治疗和干预相关,会产生危害和成本而无任何益处。过度诊断还会使医疗保健专业人员偏离对其他健康问题的关注。预防过度诊断需要提高医疗保健专业人员和患者对其发生的认识,避免不必要和无针对性的诊断测试,以及避免在没有已证明益处的情况下进行筛查。此外,系统地权衡筛查和诊断测试的危害和益处,并根据预期的绝对风险降低来确定风险因素阈值,也将有助于预防过度诊断。