O'Neill Suzanne C, Tercyak Kenneth P, Baytop Chanza, Hensley Alford Sharon, McBride Colleen M
Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, Washington, D.C., USA.
Public Health Genomics. 2015;18(2):104-12. doi: 10.1159/000370101. Epub 2015 Jan 21.
Personal genomic testing (PGT) for common disease risk is becoming increasingly frequent, but little is known about people's array of emotional reactions to learning their genomic risk profiles and the psychological harms/benefits of PGT. We conducted a study of post-PGT affect, including positive, neutral, and negative states that may arise after testing.
A total of 228 healthy adults received PGT for common disease variants and completed a semistructured research interview within 2 weeks of disclosure. The study participants reported how the PGT results made them feel in their own words. Using an iterative coding process, the responses were organized into three broad affective categories: negative, neutral, and positive affect.
Neutral affect was the most prevalent response (53.9%), followed by positive affect (26.9%) and negative affect (19.2%). We found no differences by gender, race, or education.
While <20% of participants reported negative affect in response to learning their genomic risk profile for common diseases, a majority experienced either neutral or positive emotions. These findings contribute to the growing evidence that PGT does not impose significant psychological harms. Moreover, they point to a need to better link theories and assessments in both emotional and cognitive processing to capitalize on PGT information for healthy behavior change.
针对常见疾病风险的个人基因组检测(PGT)越来越频繁,但对于人们了解其基因组风险概况后的一系列情绪反应以及PGT的心理危害/益处知之甚少。我们开展了一项关于PGT后影响的研究,包括检测后可能出现的积极、中性和消极状态。
共有228名健康成年人接受了常见疾病变异的PGT检测,并在结果披露后的2周内完成了一次半结构化研究访谈。研究参与者用自己的话描述了PGT结果给他们带来的感受。通过迭代编码过程,将回答整理为三大情感类别:消极、中性和积极情感。
中性情感是最普遍的反应(53.9%),其次是积极情感(26.9%)和消极情感(19.2%)。我们发现性别、种族或教育程度方面没有差异。
虽然不到20%的参与者在得知自己常见疾病的基因组风险概况后报告了消极情感,但大多数人经历的是中性或积极情绪。这些发现进一步证明了PGT不会造成重大心理危害。此外,它们还指出需要更好地将情绪和认知加工中的理论与评估联系起来,以便利用PGT信息促进健康行为改变。