Tahari Abdel K, Paidpally Vasavi, Chirindel Alin, Wahl Richard L, Subramaniam Rathan M
1 Russel H Morgan Department of Radiology and Radiological Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, 601 N Caroline St /JHOC 3235, Baltimore MD 21287.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2015 Feb;204(2):402-7. doi: 10.2214/AJR.14.12719.
OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of liver mean standardized uptake value normalized to lean body mass (SULmean) in the same patients at different time points within the right lobe of the liver at (18)F-FDG PET/CT, in a clinical setting. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Two PET/CT studies performed on two different dates from each of 130 patients who had normal livers according to structural imaging were included in this reader study. The mean (± SD) length of time between the studies was 235 ± 192 days. SULmean was measured with a 30-mm diameter spherical volume of interest (VOI) placed within the right lobe of the liver (above, below, and at the level of the main portal vein) by two expert readers. ANOVA, intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and Bland-Altman analysis were performed. RESULTS. The ICC for the first and second set of studies varied between 0.487 and 0.535 for reader 1 and between 0.472 and 0.545 for reader 2. The mean percentage variation for SULmean between the two time scans for the VOIs placed above, below, and at the level of the main portal vein were 3.55% ± 23.19%, 4.65% ± 23.87%, and 4.30% ± 23.03%, respectively, for reader 1 and 4.49% ± 23.23%, 4.33% ± 23.74%, and 4.48% ± 23.01%, respectively, for reader 2. Using 95% CI, the reference range for intrapatient variations between the studies in liver SULmean was -0.5 to 0.60. CONCLUSION. There is only fair repeatability of liver SULmean measured between two time points in the same patient in a clinical setting. Scan-to-scan intrapatient variation in absolute liver SULmean was -0.5 to 0.60.
目的。本研究的目的是在临床环境中,评估在(18)F-FDG PET/CT检查时,同一患者肝脏右叶不同时间点的肝脏平均标准化摄取值(SULmean)相对于去脂体重的重复性。材料与方法。本读者研究纳入了130例根据结构成像显示肝脏正常的患者,他们在两个不同日期进行了两次PET/CT检查。两次检查之间的平均(±标准差)时间间隔为235±192天。由两位专家读者使用直径30毫米的球形感兴趣区(VOI)测量肝脏右叶(在主门静脉上方、下方及主门静脉水平)的SULmean。进行了方差分析、组内相关系数(ICC)分析和Bland-Altman分析。结果。读者1的第一组和第二组研究的ICC在0.487至0.535之间,读者2的ICC在0.472至0.545之间。对于读者1,放置在主门静脉上方、下方及主门静脉水平的VOI在两次时间扫描之间SULmean的平均百分比变化分别为3.55%±23.19%、4.65%±23.87%和4.30%±23.03%;对于读者2,相应的值分别为4.49%±23.23%、4.33%±23.74%和4.48%±23.01%。使用95%置信区间,同一患者两次检查之间肝脏SULmean的患者内变异参考范围为-0.5至0.60。结论。在临床环境中,同一患者两个时间点测量的肝脏SULmean的重复性仅为中等。患者内扫描间肝脏绝对SULmean的变异为-0.5至0.60。