Hillis Christopher M, Schimmer Aaron D, Couban Stephen, Crowther Mark A
Department of Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada,
Ann Hematol. 2015 Apr;94(4):541-5. doi: 10.1007/s00277-015-2304-4. Epub 2015 Feb 1.
Choosing Wisely Canada (CWC), a medical stewardship campaign, encourages dialogue between physicians and patients to promote high-quality decision-making. Medical societies develop lists of tests, treatments, and procedures that are unnecessary, reduce value, and may cause harm. The Canadian Hematology Society (CHS) elicited suggestions for CWC recommendations from its members and received 35 unique suggestions. A working group rated these based on their potential for harm, benefit, frequency of use and value. Twelve highly ranked items were subjected to systematic evidence review. The final items were included in the list if they were of sufficient evidence base and met pre-defined core principles. The CHS-CWC recommendations are: to avoid IVIG treatment for asymptomatic immune thrombocytopenia, not bridge warfarin in low-risk patients going for procedures, not perform thrombophilia testing in the workup of early pregnancy loss, avoid fine-needle aspiration in lymphoma diagnosis, and not transfuse red blood cells for an arbitrary hemoglobin threshold. Through implementation of these recommendations, physicians will reduce potential harm to patients and increase the value of health care.
加拿大明智选择组织(CWC)是一项医疗管理活动,鼓励医生与患者之间展开对话,以促进高质量决策。医学协会制定了不必要、降低价值且可能造成伤害的检查、治疗和操作清单。加拿大血液学协会(CHS)向其成员征集有关CWC建议的意见,并收到了35条独特建议。一个工作组根据这些建议造成伤害的可能性、益处、使用频率和价值进行了评级。对排名靠前的12项建议进行了系统的证据审查。如果最终项目有足够的证据基础并符合预先定义的核心原则,就会被列入清单。CHS-CWC的建议包括:避免对无症状免疫性血小板减少症进行静脉注射免疫球蛋白治疗;对低风险患者进行手术时不使用华法林过渡;在早期流产检查中不进行血栓形成倾向检测;在淋巴瘤诊断中避免细针穿刺;以及不因任意血红蛋白阈值而输注红细胞。通过实施这些建议,医生将减少对患者的潜在伤害,并提高医疗保健的价值。