Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
School of Public Health, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
J Occup Med Toxicol. 2015 Feb 26;10:8. doi: 10.1186/s12995-015-0053-x. eCollection 2015.
Greenhouse workers are exposed to organic dusts, and they are thereby at risk of developing airway disorders. This study aims to measure personal endotoxin exposure, assess respiratory symptoms and measure fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) among female flower farm workers in Ethiopia.
A cross-sectional study involving female workers (n = 248) from four flower farms was conducted. The workers were interviewed for respiratory symptoms using a standard questionnaire. Workers from two of these farms also participated in personal endotoxin sampling (46 workers, 75 measurements) on glass fiber filters (0.2 μm pore size) inside conductive 25 mm Millipore cassettes for sampling of the "total dust" fraction. They also participated in FeNO (n = 114) measurements with a portable electrochemistry-based sensor. Chi-square and independent t-tests were used to compare categorical and continuous variables respectively. A mixed-effects model was used to analyze exposure determinants.
Endotoxin exposure had a geometric mean (GM) of 22.8 endotoxin units (EU)/m(3) with a maximum of 180 EU/m(3). Greenhouse workers had significantly higher endotoxin exposure than workers outside the greenhouses (GM = 26.7 vs. 19.3 EU/m(3) respectively; p < 0.05). The mean age of the workers was 24 years, and their mean working time in the flower farm was 21 months. Greenhouse workers had higher prevalence of self-reported respiratory symptoms than those outside greenhouses. However, after adjusting for education only blocked nose remained significant. The FeNO concentration ranged 5-166 ppb (GM = 14 ppb). Two workers had FeNO concentration above 50 ppb. FeNO levels differs significantly between the farms but there was no difference between workers inside and outside greenhouses.
Greenhouse workers at flower farms had higher prevalence of blocked nose than workers outside, which may indicate the presence of rhinitis. Endotoxin exposure was low. There were few workers with objective signs of airway inflammation; this might be because the mean working time in the greenhouses was only two years. We suggest further studies to evaluate the effect of longer employment and exposure time as well as to investigate possible exposure to pesticides and other components in the bio-aerosols.
温室工人会接触到有机粉尘,因此他们有患气道疾病的风险。本研究旨在测量埃塞俄比亚女性花卉农场工人的个体内毒素暴露情况、评估呼吸症状并测量呼出气一氧化氮分数(FeNO)。
进行了一项涉及四家花卉农场的女性工人(n=248)的横断面研究。工人通过标准问卷报告呼吸症状。其中两家农场的工人还参与了个人内毒素采样(46 名工人,75 次测量),使用带有导电 25mm Millipore 盒的玻璃纤维过滤器(0.2μm 孔径)对“总粉尘”部分进行采样。他们还参与了便携式基于电化学的传感器的 FeNO(n=114)测量。卡方检验和独立 t 检验分别用于比较分类变量和连续变量。混合效应模型用于分析暴露决定因素。
内毒素暴露的几何平均值(GM)为 22.8 内毒素单位(EU)/m3,最大值为 180 EU/m3。温室工人的内毒素暴露明显高于温室外的工人(GM 分别为 26.7 和 19.3 EU/m3;p<0.05)。工人的平均年龄为 24 岁,在花卉农场的平均工作时间为 21 个月。温室工人报告的呼吸症状患病率高于温室外的工人。然而,仅调整教育后,鼻塞仍然是显著的。FeNO 浓度范围为 5-166 ppb(GM=14 ppb)。两名工人的 FeNO 浓度高于 50 ppb。农场之间的 FeNO 水平差异显著,但温室内外的工人之间没有差异。
花卉农场的温室工人鼻塞患病率高于温室外的工人,这可能表明存在鼻炎。内毒素暴露水平较低。只有少数工人出现气道炎症的客观迹象;这可能是因为在温室中的平均工作时间仅为两年。我们建议进一步研究,以评估更长的就业和暴露时间的影响,以及调查生物气溶胶中可能接触到的农药和其他成分。