Haghighi Mahnaz, Khaterizadeh Maedeh, Chalbianloo Gholamreza, Toobaei Sholeh, Ghanizadeh Ahmad
Faculty of Medicine, Islamic Azad University, Kazerron Branch, Iran.
Islamic Azad University, Arsanjan, Iran.
Iran J Psychiatry. 2014 Oct;9(4):222-7.
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is the most common behavioral problem during childhood and in school-aged children. Various projection drawings have been designed for assessing children's personality and psychological disorders including the tests of draw a person (DAP) and draw a family (DAF). We aimed to compare the differences between typically developing children and children with ADHD using these tests.
In this case-control study, all the 9-10 year-old boy students studying at the third and fourth grades were enrolled from schools in the 2nd educational district of Shiraz, south of Iran. Eighty students were then selected and enrolled into the ADHD group and the control group. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition- text Revised (DSM-IV-TR), and the Child Symptoms Inventory were used to diagnose the children with ADHD. We evaluated and analyzed impulsiveness, non-impulsiveness, emotional problems and incompatibility indices in the DAP and DAF tests in each group.
A significant difference was found in the indices of incompatibility and emotional problems, impulsiveness, non-impulsiveness and DAF between typically developing children and those with ADHD. The mean (±SD) total scores of the above mentioned indices in the ADHD group were 19.79(±2.94), 12.31(±1.84), 5.26(±2.29) and 5.89(±2.13), respectively (P<0.001). The corresponding figures for these indices in the normal group were 12.11(±4.74), 5.63(±2), 10.36± (2.33) and 2.88(±2.13), respectively (P<0.001).
Significant differences were obtained between the control group and children with ADHD using these two drawing tests. The rate of impulsivity and emotional problems indices in drawings of children with ADHD was markedly more common than those of the typically developing children. This suggests the need for further assessment to screen ADHD.
注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)是儿童期及学龄儿童中最常见的行为问题。已经设计了各种投射绘图来评估儿童的个性和心理障碍,包括画人测验(DAP)和画家庭测验(DAF)。我们旨在使用这些测验比较正常发育儿童与ADHD儿童之间的差异。
在这项病例对照研究中,从伊朗南部设拉子第二教育区的学校招募了所有9 - 10岁的三年级和四年级男学生。然后选择80名学生并将其纳入ADHD组和对照组。使用《精神障碍诊断与统计手册》第4版修订版(DSM-IV-TR)和儿童症状量表来诊断ADHD儿童。我们评估并分析了每组中DAP和DAF测验中的冲动性、非冲动性、情绪问题和不相容性指数。
正常发育儿童与ADHD儿童在不相容性、情绪问题、冲动性、非冲动性和DAF指数方面存在显著差异。ADHD组上述指数的平均(±标准差)总分分别为19.79(±2.94)、12.31(±1.84)、5.26(±2.29)和5.89(±2.13)(P<0.001)。正常组中这些指数的相应数字分别为12.11(±4.74)、5.63(±2)、10.36±(2.33)和2.88(±2.13)(P<0.001)。
使用这两种绘图测验,对照组与ADHD儿童之间存在显著差异。ADHD儿童绘画中的冲动性和情绪问题指数明显比正常发育儿童更为常见。这表明需要进一步评估以筛查ADHD。