Stein Jeffrey S, Renda C Renee, Barker Shayne M, Liston Kennan J, Shahan Timothy A, Madden Gregory J
the Department of Psychology, Utah State University, Logan, Utah.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2015 May;39(5):932-40. doi: 10.1111/acer.12713. Epub 2015 Apr 1.
Prior human research indicates robust, positive relations between impulsive choice (i.e., preference for smaller, immediate over larger, delayed rewards) and alcohol use disorders. However, varied findings in the nonhuman literature reveal a relatively ambiguous relation between impulsive choice and alcohol consumption in rodents. In addition, few rodent studies have investigated potential relations between impulsive choice and common covariates of alcohol consumption (e.g., avidity for sweet substances or anxiety-like behavior).
Ninety-two male Long-Evans rats completed an impulsive-choice task. From this larger sample, extreme high- and low-impulsive groups (n = 30 each) were retained for further testing. In separate tests, subsequent open-field behavior and consumption of oral alcohol (12% w/v) and isocaloric sucrose were examined. Impulsive choice was then retested to examine whether behavior remained stable over the course of the experiment.
No significant relations emerged between impulsive choice and either alcohol or sucrose consumption. However, impulsive choice predicted greater anxiety-like behavior (avoidance of the center field, defecation) in the open-field test. In turn, greater anxiety predicted lower alcohol and sucrose consumption. Finally, choice remained generally stable across the experiment, although high-impulsive rats tended toward less impulsive choice in the retest.
Although impulsive choice and alcohol consumption appear to share some variance with anxiety-like behavior, the present data offer no support for a relation between impulsive choice and alcohol consumption in Long-Evans rats. Together with mixed rodent data from prior reports, these findings attenuate cross-species comparisons to human relations between impulsive choice and alcohol use disorders.
先前的人体研究表明,冲动选择(即偏好较小的即时奖励而非较大的延迟奖励)与酒精使用障碍之间存在强烈的正相关关系。然而,非人类文献中的各种研究结果显示,啮齿动物的冲动选择与酒精消费之间的关系相对模糊。此外,很少有啮齿动物研究调查冲动选择与酒精消费的常见协变量(如对甜味物质的喜好或焦虑样行为)之间的潜在关系。
92只雄性长 Evans 大鼠完成了一项冲动选择任务。从这个较大的样本中,保留了极端高冲动组和低冲动组(每组 n = 30)进行进一步测试。在单独的测试中,检查了随后的旷场行为以及口服酒精(12% w/v)和等热量蔗糖的消费量。然后重新测试冲动选择,以检查行为在实验过程中是否保持稳定。
冲动选择与酒精或蔗糖消费之间均未出现显著关系。然而,在旷场试验中,冲动选择预示着更强的焦虑样行为(避开中央区域、排便)。反过来,更强的焦虑预示着更低的酒精和蔗糖消费量。最后,尽管高冲动大鼠在重新测试中倾向于做出较少冲动的选择,但整个实验过程中的选择总体上保持稳定。
虽然冲动选择和酒精消费似乎与焦虑样行为存在一些共同差异,但目前的数据并不支持长 Evans 大鼠的冲动选择与酒精消费之间存在关联。结合先前报告中啮齿动物的混合数据,这些发现削弱了将冲动选择与酒精使用障碍之间的人类关系进行跨物种比较的可能性。