Macken Bill, Taylor John, Jones Dylan
School of Psychology, Cardiff University Cardiff, UK.
Front Psychol. 2015 Mar 23;6:293. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00293. eCollection 2015.
The notion of capacity-limited processing systems is a core element of cognitive accounts of limited and variable performance, enshrined within the short-term memory construct. We begin with a detailed critical analysis of the conceptual bases of this view and argue that there are fundamental problems - ones that go to the heart of cognitivism more generally - that render it untenable. In place of limited capacity systems, we propose a framework for explaining performance that focuses on the dynamic interplay of three aspects of any given setting: the particular task that must be accomplished, the nature and form of the material upon which the task must be performed, and the repertoire of skills and perceptual-motor functions possessed by the participant. We provide empirical examples of the applications of this framework in areas of performance typically accounted for by reference to capacity-limited short-term memory processes.
容量受限处理系统的概念是对表现有限且多变的认知解释的核心要素,它体现在短期记忆结构中。我们首先对这一观点的概念基础进行详细的批判性分析,并认为存在一些根本性问题——这些问题更广泛地触及认知主义的核心——使其难以成立。我们提出了一个用于解释表现的框架,以取代容量受限系统,该框架关注任何给定情境的三个方面之间的动态相互作用:必须完成的特定任务、执行该任务所依据的材料的性质和形式,以及参与者所具备的技能和感知运动功能的全部技能。我们提供了该框架在通常通过参考容量受限的短期记忆过程来解释的表现领域中的应用的实证例子。