Brabrand Mikkel, Lassen Annmarie Touborg, Knudsen Torben, Hallas Jesper
Department of Medicine, Sydvestjysk Sygehus, Esbjerg, Denmark; Centre South Western Denmark, Institute of Regional Health Research-University of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Odense University Hospital, Odense, Denmark.
PLoS One. 2015 Apr 13;10(4):e0122480. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0122480. eCollection 2015.
Most existing risk stratification systems predicting mortality in emergency departments or admission units are complex in clinical use or have not been validated to a level where use is considered appropriate. We aimed to develop and validate a simple system that predicts seven-day mortality of acutely admitted medical patients using routinely collected variables obtained within the first minutes after arrival.
This observational prospective cohort study used three independent cohorts at the medical admission units at a regional teaching hospital and a tertiary university hospital and included all adult (≥ 15 years) patients. Multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to identify the clinical variables that best predicted the endpoint. From this, we developed a simplified model that can be calculated without specialized tools or loss of predictive ability. The outcome was defined as seven-day all-cause mortality. 76 patients (2.5%) met the endpoint in the development cohort, 57 (2.0%) in the first validation cohort, and 111 (4.3%) in the second. Systolic blood Pressure, Age, Respiratory rate, loss of Independence, and peripheral oxygen Saturation were associated with the endpoint (full model). Based on this, we developed a simple score (range 0-5), ie, the PARIS score, by dichotomizing the variables. The ability to identify patients at increased risk (discriminatory power and calibration) was excellent for all three cohorts using both models. For patients with a PARIS score ≥ 3, sensitivity was 62.5-74.0%, specificity 85.9-91.1%, positive predictive value 11.2-17.5%, and negative predictive value 98.3-99.3%. Patients with a score ≤ 1 had a low mortality (≤ 1%); with 2, intermediate mortality (2-5%); and ≥ 3, high mortality (≥ 10%).
Seven-day mortality can be predicted upon admission with high sensitivity and specificity and excellent negative predictive values.
大多数现有的预测急诊科或住院部死亡率的风险分层系统在临床应用中较为复杂,或者尚未经过验证达到可被认为适用的水平。我们旨在开发并验证一种简单的系统,该系统利用患者到达后最初几分钟内常规收集的变量来预测急性入院内科患者的七天死亡率。
这项观察性前瞻性队列研究在一家地区教学医院和一家三级大学医院的内科住院部使用了三个独立队列,纳入了所有成年(≥15岁)患者。采用多变量逻辑回归分析来确定最能预测终点的临床变量。据此,我们开发了一个简化模型,该模型无需专门工具即可计算,且不会损失预测能力。结局定义为七天全因死亡率。在开发队列中有76例患者(2.5%)达到终点,在第一个验证队列中有57例(2.0%),在第二个验证队列中有111例(4.3%)。收缩压、年龄、呼吸频率、生活不能自理和外周血氧饱和度与终点相关(完整模型)。基于此,我们通过对变量进行二分法开发了一个简单评分(范围0 - 5),即PARIS评分。使用这两个模型,对于所有三个队列,识别风险增加患者的能力(辨别力和校准)都非常出色。对于PARIS评分≥3的患者,敏感性为62.5 - 74.0%,特异性为85.9 - 91.1%,阳性预测值为11.2 - 17.5%,阴性预测值为98.3 - 99.3%。评分≤1的患者死亡率较低(≤1%);评分为2的患者死亡率中等(2 - 5%);评分≥3的患者死亡率较高(≥10%)。
入院时可通过高敏感性、特异性和出色的阴性预测值来预测七天死亡率。