Turvey Samuel T, Trung Cao Tien, Quyet Vo Dai, Nhu Hoang Van, Thoai Do Van, Tuan Vo Cong Anh, Hoa Dang Thi, Kacha Kouvang, Sysomphone Thongsay, Wallate Sousakhone, Hai Chau Thi Thanh, Thanh Nguyen Van, Wilkinson Nicholas M
Institute of Zoology, Zoological Society of London Regent's Park, London, NW1 4RY, UK.
Faculty of Zoology, Vinh University Vinh, Nghe An Province, Vietnam.
J Appl Ecol. 2015 Apr;52(2):422-433. doi: 10.1111/1365-2664.12382. Epub 2014 Dec 18.
The use of robust ecological data to make evidence-based management decisions is frequently prevented by limited data quantity or quality, and local ecological knowledge (LEK) is increasingly seen as an important source of information for conservation. However, there has been little assessment of LEK's usefulness for informing prioritization and management of landscapes for threatened species, or assessing comparative species status across landscapes.A large-scale interview survey in the Annamite Mountains (Vietnam and Lao PDR) compiled the first systematic LEK data set for saola , one of the world's rarest mammals, and eight other ungulates. Saola conservation is hindered by uncertainty over continued presence across much of its proposed distribution. We analysed comparative LEK-based last-sighting data across three landscapes to determine whether regional sighting histories support previous suggestions of landscape importance for saola conservation (Hue-Quang Nam: top-priority Vietnamese landscape; Pu Mat: lower priority Vietnamese landscape; Viengthong: high-priority Lao landscape) and whether they constitute an effective spatial prioritization tool for cryptic species management.Wild pig and red muntjac may be the only Annamite ungulates with stable populations; the regional status of all other species appears to be worse. Saola have declined more severely and/or are significantly rarer than most other ungulates and have been seen by relatively few respondents. Saola were also frequently considered locally rarest or declining, and never as species that had not declined.In contrast to other species, there are no regional differences in saola sighting histories, with continued persistence in all landscapes challenging suggestions that regional status differs greatly. Remnant populations persist in Vietnam despite heavy hunting, but even remote landscapes in Lao may be under intense pressure.. Our local ecological knowledge data suggest that intact saola populations probably no longer exist, but individuals persist in all three landscapes, making management activities to reduce hunting pressure on ungulates in each landscape a conservation priority. Analysis of last-sighting histories can constitute an important conservation tool when robust data are otherwise unavailable, and collection of last-sighting records should be incorporated more widely into field studies and management of other highly threatened, cryptic species. Our local ecological knowledge data suggest that intact saola populations probably no longer exist, but individuals persist in all three landscapes, making management activities to reduce hunting pressure on ungulates in each landscape a conservation priority. Analysis of last-sighting histories can constitute an important conservation tool when robust data are otherwise unavailable, and collection of last-sighting records should be incorporated more widely into field studies and management of other highly threatened, cryptic species.
数据数量或质量有限常常阻碍人们利用可靠的生态数据做出基于证据的管理决策,而地方生态知识(LEK)日益被视为保护工作的重要信息来源。然而,对于地方生态知识在为受威胁物种的景观优先排序和管理提供信息,或评估不同景观中物种的相对状况方面的作用,几乎没有进行过评估。在安南山脉(越南和老挝)开展的一项大规模访谈调查,汇编了世界上最珍稀的哺乳动物之一中南大羚以及其他八种有蹄类动物的首个系统性地方生态知识数据集。中南大羚的保护工作因在其大部分推测分布区域内是否仍有该物种存在的不确定性而受阻。我们分析了基于地方生态知识的三个景观区域的末次目击数据,以确定区域目击历史是否支持此前关于中南大羚保护景观重要性的观点(顺化 - 广平:越南的首要优先景观;普马特:越南的较低优先景观;丰通:老挝的高优先景观),以及这些数据是否构成一种有效的空间优先排序工具,用于隐秘物种的管理。野猪和赤麂可能是安南山脉中仅有的种群稳定的有蹄类动物;其他所有物种的区域状况似乎更糟。中南大羚的数量下降更为严重,而且/或者明显比大多数其他有蹄类动物更为稀少,只有相对较少的受访者见过它们。中南大羚在当地也常常被认为是最珍稀或数量在减少的物种,从未被视为数量未减少的物种。与其他物种不同,中南大羚的目击历史在各区域没有差异,在所有景观区域中都有该物种持续存在,这对区域状况差异很大的观点提出了挑战。尽管捕猎严重,越南仍有残余种群存在,但即使是老挝偏远的景观区域可能也面临着巨大压力。我们的地方生态知识数据表明,完整的中南大羚种群可能已不复存在,但个体仍存在于所有三个景观区域,因此在每个景观区域开展管理活动以减轻对有蹄类动物的捕猎压力成为保护工作的重点。当无法获取可靠数据时,分析末次目击历史可以构成一项重要的保护工具,末次目击记录的收集应更广泛地纳入其他高度濒危、隐秘物种的野外研究和管理工作中。我们的地方生态知识数据表明,完整的中南大羚种群可能已不复存在,但个体仍存在于所有三个景观区域,因此在每个景观区域开展管理活动以减轻对有蹄类动物的捕猎压力成为保护工作的重点。当无法获取可靠数据时,分析末次目击历史可以构成一项重要的保护工具,末次目击记录的收集应更广泛地纳入其他高度濒危、隐秘物种的野外研究和管理工作中。