Meuwly Cyrill, Chowdhury Tumul, Sandu Nora, Reck Martin, Erne Paul, Schaller Bernhard
From the University Hospital, 4031 Basel, Switzerland (CM, MR); Cardiology Luzerner Kantonsspital, 6000 Luzern, Switzerland (PE); Present address: Cardiology, St Anna Clinic, St Anna Strasse 32, 6006 Luzern, Switzerland (PE); Departments of Anesthesia and Perioperative Medicine, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada (TC); and Department of Research, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK (NS, BS).
Medicine (Baltimore). 2015 May;94(18):e807. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000000807.
Trigeminocardiac reflex (TCR) is defined as sudden onset of parasympathetic dysrhythmia including hypotension, apnea, and gastric hypermotility during stimulation of any branches of the trigeminal nerve. Previous publications imply a relation between TCR and depth of anesthesia. To gain more detailed insights into this hypothesis, we performed a systematic literature review.Literature about occurrence of TCR was systematically identified through searching in Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), PubMed (MEDLINE), EMBASE (Ovid SP), and the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI Web of Sciences) databases until June 2013, as well as reference lists of articles for risk calculation. In this study, TCR was defined as drop in mean arterial blood pressure and heart rate, both >20% to baseline. We calculated intraoperative cerebral state index (CSI) of each TCR-case using a newly developed method. These data were further divided into 3 subgroups: CSI <40 (deep anesthesia), CSI 40-60 (regular anesthesia), and CSI >60 (slight anesthesia).Including 45 studies with 910 patients, 140 (15%) presented with TCR, and 770 (85%) without TCR during operation. TCR occurrence showed a 1.2-fold higher pooled risk slighter anesthesia (CSI <40: 13%, at CSI 40-60: 21%, and at CSI >60: 27%) compared with deeper anesthesia. In addition, we could discover a 1.3-fold higher pooled risk of higher MABP drop with a strong negative correlation (r = -0.935; r = 0.89) and a 4.5-fold higher pooled risk of asystole during TCR under slight anesthesia compared with deeper anesthesia.Our work is the first systematic review about TCR and demonstrates clear evidence for TCR occurrence and a more severe course of the TCR in slight anesthesia underlying the importance of skills in anesthesia management during skull base surgery. Furthermore, we have introduced a new standard method to calculate the depth of anesthesia.
三叉神经心脏反射(TCR)被定义为在刺激三叉神经的任何分支时突然出现的副交感神经节律失常,包括低血压、呼吸暂停和胃肠蠕动亢进。先前的出版物暗示了TCR与麻醉深度之间的关系。为了更深入地了解这一假设,我们进行了一项系统的文献综述。
通过检索Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)、PubMed(MEDLINE)、EMBASE(Ovid SP)和科学信息研究所(ISI Web of Sciences)数据库直至2013年6月,以及文章的参考文献列表以进行风险计算,系统地识别了有关TCR发生的文献。在本研究中,TCR被定义为平均动脉血压和心率下降,两者均比基线下降>20%。我们使用一种新开发的方法计算每个TCR病例的术中脑状态指数(CSI)。这些数据进一步分为3个亚组:CSI<40(深度麻醉)、CSI 40 - 六十(常规麻醉)和CSI>60(轻度麻醉)。
纳入45项研究共910例患者,其中140例(15%)在手术期间出现TCR,770例(85%)未出现TCR。与深度麻醉相比,TCR的发生在轻度麻醉(CSI<40:13%,CSI 40 - 60:21%,CSI>60:27%)时合并风险高1.2倍。此外,我们发现与深度麻醉相比,在轻度麻醉下TCR期间较高的平均动脉血压下降合并风险高1.3倍,且呈强负相关(r = -0.935;r = 0.89),以及心脏停搏的合并风险高4.5倍。
我们的工作是关于TCR的首次系统综述,并证明了TCR发生的明确证据以及在轻度麻醉下TCR病程更严重,这突出了颅底手术麻醉管理技能的重要性。此外,我们引入了一种计算麻醉深度的新标准方法。