Martínez-González Nahara Anani, Rosemann Thomas, Djalali Sima, Huber-Geismann Flore, Tandjung Ryan
Institute of Primary Care, University of Zurich, University Hospital of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Institute of Primary Care, University of Zurich, University Hospital of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Med Care Res Rev. 2015 Aug;72(4):395-418. doi: 10.1177/1077558715586297. Epub 2015 May 12.
Task-shifting from physicians to nurses has gained increasing interest in health policy but little is known about its efficiency. This systematic review was conducted to compare resource utilization with task-shifting from physicians to nurses in primary care. Literature searches yielded 4,589 citations. Twenty studies comprising 13,171 participants met the inclusion criteria. Meta-analyses showed nurses had more return consultations and longer consultations than physicians but were similar in their use of referrals, prescriptions, or investigations. The evidence has limitations, but suggests that the effects may be influenced by the utilization of resources, context of care, available guidance, and supervision. Cost data suggest physician-nurse salary and physician's time spent on supervision and delegation are important components of nurse-led care costs. More rigorous research involving a wider range of nurses from many countries is needed reporting detailed accounts of nurses' roles and competencies, qualifications, training, resources, time available for consultations, and all-cause costs.
从医生到护士的任务转移在卫生政策方面越来越受到关注,但对其效率却知之甚少。本系统评价旨在比较初级保健中从医生到护士任务转移后的资源利用情况。文献检索共获得4589条引文。20项研究(涉及13171名参与者)符合纳入标准。荟萃分析表明,与医生相比,护士的复诊次数更多、会诊时间更长,但在转诊、开处方或进行检查方面的使用情况相似。证据存在局限性,但表明其效果可能受到资源利用、护理环境、可用指导和监督的影响。成本数据表明,医生-护士工资以及医生用于监督和授权的时间是护士主导护理成本的重要组成部分。需要开展更严格的研究,涵盖来自许多国家的更广泛的护士群体,报告护士的角色和能力、资质、培训、资源、会诊可用时间以及全因成本的详细情况。