Ingholt Liselotte, Sørensen Betina Bang, Andersen Susan, Zinckernagel Line, Friis-Holmberg Teresa, Frank Vibeke Asmussen, Stock Christiane, Tjørnhøj-Thomsen Tine, Rod Morten Hulvej
Centre for Intervention Research in Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Øster Farimagsgade 5A 2nd floor, DK-1353, Copenhagen K, Denmark.
Centre for Alcohol and Drug Research, Aarhus University, Bartholins Alle 10, 3, DK-8000, Aarhus C, Denmark.
BMC Public Health. 2015 May 22;15:502. doi: 10.1186/s12889-015-1831-1.
This article describes the rationale and contents of an intervention program aimed at strengthening students' social relations in order to reduce dropout from vocational schools in Denmark. Taking its theoretical cue from the concept of 'social participation', a qualitative study was performed to investigate the specific relationships between the social environment within the schools and the institutional structures in order to analyse reasons for school dropout and their relation to well-being, cigarette smoking and substance use.
The development study was based on ethnographic methods, including 22 qualitative interviews with students 17-19 years old and fieldwork with participant observations at four vocational schools over 40 days, including informal interviews and discussion meetings with managers, teachers, counselors and students. As part of the fieldwork, four additional qualitative interviews and four group interviews were conducted with students 16-25 years old.
The qualitative data collection resulted in seven major themes to be addressed in the intervention: social relations, sole focus on professional skills, institutionalized individualization, importance of the introduction period, physical surroundings and schedules, tobacco and cannabis use and communication about drug use. The program addressing these themes incorporates suggestions that are meant to improve how teachers welcome new students, to enable greater integration of social and educational activities and to enhance the capacity of teachers and counselors to deal with drug use problems among students.
The development of new intervention programs might benefit from adopting a theoretical and methodological perspective that enables a closer exploration of the everyday social practices in which interventions are embedded. Thus, we aimed to create a comprehensive intervention that worked through organizational changes in everyday school practices. Intervention programs must be planned in dialogue and collaboration with practitioners in the field to ensure the pertinence and usability of the program.
本文描述了一项干预计划的基本原理和内容,该计划旨在加强学生的社会关系,以减少丹麦职业学校的辍学率。该研究从“社会参与”概念中获取理论线索,开展了一项定性研究,以调查学校内部社会环境与制度结构之间的具体关系,从而分析辍学原因及其与幸福感、吸烟和药物使用的关系。
这项发展研究基于人种学方法,包括对17 - 19岁学生进行22次定性访谈,以及在四所职业学校进行为期40天的参与式观察实地调查,包括与管理人员、教师、辅导员和学生进行非正式访谈和讨论会议。作为实地调查的一部分,还对16 - 25岁的学生进行了另外4次定性访谈和4次小组访谈。
定性数据收集得出了干预中要解决的七个主要主题:社会关系、对专业技能的单一关注、制度化的个体化、入学初期的重要性、物理环境和日程安排、烟草和大麻使用以及关于药物使用的交流。针对这些主题的计划纳入了一些建议,旨在改善教师迎接新生的方式,使社会活动和教育活动能更好地融合,并提高教师和辅导员处理学生药物使用问题的能力。
新干预计划的制定可能受益于采用一种理论和方法视角,以便更深入地探索干预所嵌入的日常社会实践。因此,我们旨在创建一项通过日常学校实践中的组织变革来发挥作用的综合干预措施。干预计划必须与该领域的从业者进行对话和合作来制定,以确保计划的针对性和实用性。