Carrara Marta, Carozzi Luca, Moss Travis J, de Pasquale Marco, Cerutti Sergio, Ferrario Manuela, Lake Douglas E, Moorman J Randall
Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, P.zza Leonardo da Vinci 32, Milan, Italy.
Physiol Meas. 2015 Sep;36(9):1873-88. doi: 10.1088/0967-3334/36/9/1873. Epub 2015 Aug 6.
Atrial fibrillation (AF) is usually detected by inspection of the electrocardiogram waveform, a task made difficult when the signal is distorted by noise. The RR interval time series is more frequently available and accurate, yet linear and nonlinear time series analyses that detect highly varying and irregular AF are vulnerable to the common finding of frequent ectopy. We hypothesized that different nonlinear measures might capture characteristic features of AF, normal sinus rhythm (NSR), and sinus rhythm (SR) with frequent ectopy in ways that linear measures might not. To test this, we studied 2722 patients with 24 h ECG recordings in the University of Virginia Holter database. We found dynamical phenotypes for the three rhythm classifications. As expected, AF records had the highest variability and entropy, and NSR the lowest. SR with ectopy could be distinguished from AF, which had higher entropy, and from NSR, which had different fractal scaling, measured as higher detrended fluctuation analysis slope. With these dynamical phenotypes, we developed successful classification strategies, and the nonlinear measures improved on the use of mean and variability alone, even after adjusting for age. Final models using all variables had excellent performance, with positive predictive values for AF, NSR and SR with ectopy as high as 97, 98 and 90%, respectively. Since these classifiers can reliably detect rhythm changes utilizing segments as short as 10 min, we envision their application in noisy settings and in personal monitoring devices where only RR interval time series may be available.
心房颤动(AF)通常通过检查心电图波形来检测,当信号被噪声干扰时,这项任务会变得困难。RR间期时间序列更常可用且更准确,但检测高度变化和不规则房颤的线性和非线性时间序列分析容易受到频繁异位搏动这一常见发现的影响。我们假设不同的非线性测量方法可能以线性测量方法无法做到的方式捕捉房颤、正常窦性心律(NSR)和伴有频繁异位搏动的窦性心律(SR)的特征。为了验证这一点,我们研究了弗吉尼亚大学动态心电图数据库中2722例有24小时心电图记录的患者。我们发现了三种心律分类的动态表型。正如预期的那样,房颤记录的变异性和熵最高,而NSR最低。伴有异位搏动的SR可以与熵更高的房颤以及具有不同分形标度(以更高的去趋势波动分析斜率衡量)的NSR区分开来。利用这些动态表型,我们开发了成功的分类策略,即使在调整年龄后,非线性测量方法在单独使用均值和变异性方面也有改进。使用所有变量的最终模型具有出色的性能,房颤、NSR和伴有异位搏动的SR的阳性预测值分别高达97%、98%和90%。由于这些分类器可以利用短至10分钟的片段可靠地检测心律变化,我们设想它们可应用于嘈杂环境以及仅可获得RR间期时间序列的个人监测设备中。