Devlin Alison M, McGee-Lennon Marilyn, O'Donnell Catherine A, Bouamrane Matt-Mouley, Agbakoba Ruth, O'Connor Siobhan, Grieve Eleanor, Finch Tracy, Wyke Sally, Watson Nicholas, Browne Susan, Mair Frances S
Institute of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom.
Department of Computer and Information Sciences, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, United Kingdom.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2016 Jan;23(1):48-59. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocv097. Epub 2015 Aug 8.
To identify implementation lessons from the United Kingdom Delivering Assisted Living Lifestyles at Scale (dallas) program-a large-scale, national technology program that aims to deliver a broad range of digital services and products to the public to promote health and well-being.
Prospective, longitudinal qualitative research study investigating implementation processes. Qualitative data collected includes semi-structured e-Health Implementation Toolkit-led interviews at baseline/mid-point (n = 38), quarterly evaluation, quarterly technical and barrier and solutions reports, observational logs, quarterly evaluation alignment interviews with project leads, observational data collected during meetings, and ethnographic data from dallas events (n > 200 distinct pieces of qualitative data). Data analysis was guided by Normalization Process Theory, a sociological theory that aids conceptualization of implementation issues in complex healthcare settings.
Five key challenges were identified: 1) The challenge of establishing and maintaining large heterogeneous, multi-agency partnerships to deliver new models of healthcare; 2) The need for resilience in the face of barriers and set-backs including the backdrop of continually changing external environments; 3) The inherent tension between embracing innovative co-design and achieving delivery at pace and at scale; 4) The effects of branding and marketing issues in consumer healthcare settings; and 5) The challenge of interoperability and information governance, when commercial proprietary models are dominant.
The magnitude and ambition of the dallas program provides a unique opportunity to investigate the macro level implementation challenges faced when designing and delivering digital health and wellness services at scale. Flexibility, adaptability, and resilience are key implementation facilitators when shifting to new digitally enabled models of care.
从英国大规模提供辅助生活方式(dallas)项目中识别实施经验教训。该项目是一项大规模的全国性技术项目,旨在向公众提供广泛的数字服务和产品,以促进健康和福祉。
对实施过程进行前瞻性、纵向定性研究。收集的定性数据包括在基线/中期进行的由电子健康实施工具包主导的半结构化访谈(n = 38)、季度评估、季度技术、障碍与解决方案报告、观察日志、与项目负责人进行的季度评估一致性访谈、会议期间收集的观察数据以及来自dallas活动的人种学数据(n > 200条不同的定性数据)。数据分析以规范化过程理论为指导,该理论是一种社会学理论,有助于在复杂的医疗环境中对实施问题进行概念化。
确定了五个关键挑战:1)建立和维持大型异质多机构伙伴关系以提供新型医疗模式的挑战;2)面对包括不断变化的外部环境背景在内的障碍和挫折时需要具备适应能力;3)在接受创新的共同设计与快速大规模交付之间存在的内在矛盾;4)消费者医疗环境中品牌与营销问题的影响;5)在商业专有模式占主导地位时,互操作性和信息治理方面的挑战。
dallas项目的规模和雄心为研究大规模设计和提供数字健康与福祉服务时面临的宏观层面实施挑战提供了独特机会。转向新的数字化护理模式时,灵活性、适应性和适应能力是关键的实施促进因素。