Goedhart Geertje, Kromhout Hans, Wiart Joe, Vermeulen Roel
Department of Environmental Epidemiology, Institute for Risk Assessment Sciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Whist Lab, Institut Mines Telecom and Orange Labs, Paris, France.
Occup Environ Med. 2015 Nov;72(11):812-8. doi: 10.1136/oemed-2015-102808. Epub 2015 Aug 26.
Interpretation of epidemiological studies on health effects from mobile phone use is hindered by uncertainties in the exposure assessment. We used a newly developed smartphone application (app) to validate self-reported mobile phone use and behaviour among adults.
107 participants (mean age 41.4 years) in the Netherlands either downloaded the software app on their smartphone or were provided with a study smartphone for 4 weeks. The app recorded the number and duration of calls, text messages, data transfer, laterality and hands-free use. Self-reported mobile phone use was collected before using the app and after 6 months through an interviewer-administered questionnaire.
The geometric mean ratios (GMR, 95% CI) and Spearman correlations (r) of self-reported (after 6 months) versus recorded number and duration of calls were: GMR=0.65 (0.53 to 0.80), r=0.53; and GMR=1.11 (0.86 to 1.42), r=0.57 respectively. Participants held the phone on average for 86% of the total call time near the head. Self-reported right side users held the phone for 70.7% of the total call time on the right side of the head, and left side users for 66.2% on the left side of the head. The percentage of total call time that the use of hands-free devices (headset, speaker mode, Bluetooth) was recorded increased with increasing frequency of reported hands-free device usage.
The observed recall errors and precision of reported laterality and hands-free use can be used to quantify and improve radiofrequency exposure models based on self-reported mobile phone use.
暴露评估的不确定性阻碍了对手机使用对健康影响的流行病学研究的解读。我们使用新开发的智能手机应用程序(app)来验证成年人自我报告的手机使用情况和行为。
荷兰的107名参与者(平均年龄41.4岁)要么在其智能手机上下载该软件应用程序,要么被提供一部研究用智能手机,为期4周。该应用程序记录了通话次数、时长、短信、数据传输、手机使用侧别和免提使用情况。自我报告的手机使用情况在使用该应用程序之前以及6个月后通过访员管理的问卷进行收集。
自我报告的(6个月后)与记录的通话次数和时长的几何平均比(GMR,95%可信区间)以及Spearman相关性(r)分别为:GMR = 0.65(0.53至0.80),r = 0.53;以及GMR = 1.11(0.86至1.42),r = 0.57。参与者在通话总时长中平均有86%的时间将手机靠近头部。自我报告为右侧使用手机的参与者在通话总时长中有70.7%的时间将手机放在头部右侧,左侧使用手机的参与者则有66.2%的时间将手机放在头部左侧。免提设备(耳机、扬声器模式、蓝牙)使用记录的通话总时长百分比随着报告的免提设备使用频率增加而增加。
观察到的回忆误差以及报告的使用侧别和免提使用情况的精确性可用于量化和改进基于自我报告的手机使用情况的射频暴露模型。