Griese Matthias, Irnstetter Armin, Hengst Meike, Burmester Helen, Nagel Felicitas, Ripper Jan, Feilcke Maria, Pawlita Ingo, Gothe Florian, Kappler Matthias, Schams Andrea, Wesselak Traudl, Rauch Daniela, Wittmann Thomas, Lohse Peter, Brasch Frank, Kröner Carolin
Department of Pediatric Pneumology, Dr. von Haunersches Kinderspital, University of Munich, German Center for Lung Research, Lindwurmstraße 4, 80337, Munich, Germany.
Praxis für Humangenetik, CeGaT GmbH, Tübingen, Germany.
Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2015 Sep 25;10:122. doi: 10.1186/s13023-015-0339-1.
Aim of this study was to verify a systematic and practical categorization system that allows dynamic classification of pediatric DPLD irrespective of completeness of patient data.
The study was based on 2322 children submitted to the kids-lung-register between 1997 and 2012. Of these children 791 were assigned to 12 DPLD categories, more than 2/3 belonged to categories manifesting primarily in infancy. The work-flow of the pediatric DPLD categorization system included (i) the generation of a final working diagnosis, decision on the presence or absence of (ii) DPLD and (iii) a systemic or lung only condition, and (iv) the allocation to a category and subcategory. The validity and inter-observer dependency of this workflow was re-tested using a systematic sample of 100 cases.
Two blinded raters allocated more than 80% of the re-categorized cases identically. Non-identical allocation was due to lack of appreciation of all available details, insufficient knowledge of the classification rules by the raters, incomplete patient data, and shortcomings of the classification system itself.
This study provides a suitable workflow and hand-on rules for the categorization of pediatric DPLD. Potential pitfalls were identified and a foundation was laid for the development of consensus-based, international categorization guidelines.
本研究的目的是验证一种系统且实用的分类系统,该系统能够对儿科弥漫性肺实质性疾病(DPLD)进行动态分类,而无需考虑患者数据的完整性。
该研究基于1997年至2012年间提交至儿童肺部登记处的2322名儿童。其中791名儿童被分配到12个DPLD类别,超过三分之二属于主要在婴儿期表现出的类别。儿科DPLD分类系统的工作流程包括:(i)得出最终的工作诊断,确定是否存在(ii)DPLD以及(iii)全身性疾病或仅累及肺部的疾病,以及(iv)分配到一个类别和子类别。使用100例病例的系统样本对该工作流程的有效性和观察者间的依赖性进行了重新测试。
两名盲法评估者对超过80%的重新分类病例给出了相同的分类。分类不同是由于未充分了解所有可用细节、评估者对分类规则的知识不足、患者数据不完整以及分类系统本身的缺陷。
本研究为儿科DPLD的分类提供了合适的工作流程和实用规则。识别出了潜在的陷阱,并为制定基于共识的国际分类指南奠定了基础。