Mancini Martina, El-Gohary Mahmoud, Pearson Sean, McNames James, Schlueter Heather, Nutt John G, King Laurie A, Horak Fay B
Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR, USA.
APDM, Inc., Portland, OR, USA.
NeuroRehabilitation. 2015;37(1):3-10. doi: 10.3233/NRE-151236.
Difficulty turning during gait is a major contributor to mobility disability, falls and reduced quality of life in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD). Unfortunately, the assessment of mobility in the clinic may not adequately reflect typical mobility function or its variability during daily life. We hypothesized that quality of turning mobility, rather than overall quantity of activity, would be impaired in people with PD over seven days of continuous recording.
Thirteen subjects with PD and 8 healthy control subjects of similar age wore three Opal inertial sensors (on their belt and on each foot) throughout seven consecutive days during normal daily activities. Turning metrics included average and coefficient of variation (CV) of: (1) number of turns per hour, (2) turn angle amplitude, (3) turn duration, (4) turn mean velocity, and (5) number of steps per turn. Turning characteristics during continuous monitoring were compared with turning 90 and 180 degrees in a observed gait task.
No differences were found between PD and control groups for observed turns. In contrast, subjects with PD showed impaired quality of turning compared to healthy control subjects (Turn Mean Velocity: 43.3 ± 4.8°/s versus 38 ± 5.7°/s, mean number of steps 1.7 ± 1.1 versus 3.2 ± 0.8). In addition, PD patients showed higher variability within the day and across days compared to controls. However, no differences were seen between PD and control subjects in the overall activity (number of steps per day or percent of the day walking) during the seven days.
We show that continuous monitoring of natural turning during daily activities inside or outside the home is feasible for patients with PD and the elderly. This is the first study showing that continuous monitoring of turning was more sensitive to PD than observed turns. In addition, the quality of turning characteristics was more sensitive to PD than quantity of turns. Characterizing functional turning during daily activities will address a critical barrier to rehabilitation practice and clinical trials: objective measures of mobility characteristics in real-life environments.
步态转弯困难是帕金森病(PD)患者行动能力残疾、跌倒及生活质量下降的主要原因。遗憾的是,临床中对行动能力的评估可能无法充分反映日常生活中的典型行动功能及其变异性。我们推测,在连续七天的记录中,PD患者的转弯行动质量而非活动总量会受损。
13名PD患者和8名年龄相仿的健康对照者在正常日常活动期间连续七天佩戴三个Opal惯性传感器(一个在腰部,两个分别在双脚)。转弯指标包括以下各项的平均值和变异系数(CV):(1)每小时转弯次数,(2)转弯角度幅度,(3)转弯持续时间,(4)转弯平均速度,以及(5)每次转弯步数。将连续监测期间的转弯特征与观察到的步态任务中90度和180度转弯进行比较。
在观察到的转弯方面,PD组与对照组之间未发现差异。相比之下,与健康对照者相比,PD患者的转弯质量受损(转弯平均速度:43.3±4.8°/秒对38±5.7°/秒,平均步数1.7±1.1对3.2±0.8)。此外,与对照组相比,PD患者在日内和日间表现出更高的变异性。然而,在这七天中,PD患者与对照者在总体活动(每日步数或每日行走百分比)方面未发现差异。
我们表明,对PD患者和老年人在家中或户外日常活动期间的自然转弯进行连续监测是可行的。这是第一项表明连续监测转弯比观察到的转弯对PD更敏感的研究。此外,转弯特征的质量比转弯数量对PD更敏感。对日常活动中的功能性转弯进行特征描述将解决康复实践和临床试验中的一个关键障碍:现实生活环境中行动特征的客观测量。