Rabatin Joseph, Williams Eric, Baier Manwell Linda, Schwartz Mark D, Brown Roger L, Linzer Mark
Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL, USA.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2016 Jan;7(1):41-3. doi: 10.1177/2150131915607799. Epub 2015 Sep 28.
To assess relationships between primary care work conditions, physician burnout, quality of care, and medical errors.
Cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses of data from the MEMO (Minimizing Error, Maximizing Outcome) Study. Two surveys of 422 family physicians and general internists, administered 1 year apart, queried physician job satisfaction, stress and burnout, organizational culture, and intent to leave within 2 years. A chart audit of 1795 of their adult patients with diabetes and/or hypertension assessed care quality and medical errors.
Women physicians were almost twice as likely as men to report burnout (36% vs 19%, P < .001). Burned out clinicians reported less satisfaction (P < .001), more job stress (P < .001), more time pressure during visits (P < .01), more chaotic work conditions (P < .001), and less work control (P < .001). Their workplaces were less likely to emphasize work-life balance (P < .001) and they noted more intent to leave the practice (56% vs 21%, P < .001). There were no consistent relationships between burnout, care quality, and medical errors.
Burnout is highly associated with adverse work conditions and a greater intention to leave the practice, but not with adverse patient outcomes. Care quality thus appears to be preserved at great personal cost to primary care physicians. Efforts focused on workplace redesign and physician self-care are warranted to sustain the primary care workforce.
评估基层医疗工作条件、医生职业倦怠、医疗质量和医疗差错之间的关系。
对MEMO(最小化差错,最大化结果)研究的数据进行横断面和纵向分析。对422名家庭医生和普通内科医生进行了两次间隔1年的调查,询问了医生的工作满意度、压力和职业倦怠、组织文化以及两年内离职意向。对他们的1795名成年糖尿病和/或高血压患者进行病历审核,评估医疗质量和医疗差错。
女医生报告职业倦怠的可能性几乎是男医生的两倍(36%对19%,P<.001)。职业倦怠的临床医生报告的满意度较低(P<.001)、工作压力较大(P<.001)、就诊时时间压力更大(P<.01)、工作条件更混乱(P<.001)以及工作控制权更少(P<.001)。他们的工作场所不太可能强调工作与生活的平衡(P<.001),并且他们表示有更高的离职意向(56%对21%,P<.001)。职业倦怠、医疗质量和医疗差错之间没有一致的关系。
职业倦怠与不良工作条件和更高的离职意向密切相关,但与不良患者结局无关。因此,基层医疗医生似乎是以巨大的个人代价维持了医疗质量。有必要致力于重新设计工作场所和医生自我保健,以维持基层医疗劳动力队伍。