Chin Calvin W L, Messika-Zeitoun David, Shah Anoop S V, Lefevre Guillaume, Bailleul Sophie, Yeung Emily N W, Koo Maria, Mirsadraee Saeed, Mathieu Tiffany, Semple Scott I, Mills Nicholas L, Vahanian Alec, Newby David E, Dweck Marc R
British Heart Foundation/University Centre for Cardiovascular Science, University of Edinburgh, Chancellor's Building, 49 Little France Crescent, Edinburgh EH16 4SB, UK National Heart Center Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
Cardiology Department, AP-HP, Bichat Hospital, Paris, France.
Eur Heart J. 2016 Feb 21;37(8):713-23. doi: 10.1093/eurheartj/ehv525. Epub 2015 Oct 21.
Midwall myocardial fibrosis on cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) is a marker of early ventricular decompensation and adverse outcomes in aortic stenosis (AS). We aimed to develop and validate a novel clinical score using variables associated with midwall fibrosis.
One hundred forty-seven patients (peak aortic velocity (Vmax) 3.9 [3.2,4.4] m/s) underwent CMR to determine midwall fibrosis (CMR cohort). Routine clinical variables that demonstrated significant association with midwall fibrosis were included in a multivariate logistic score. We validated the prognostic value of the score in two separate outcome cohorts of asymptomatic patients (internal: n = 127, follow-up 10.3 [5.7,11.2] years; external: n = 289, follow-up 2.6 [1.6,4.5] years). Primary outcome was a composite of AS-related events (cardiovascular death, heart failure, and new angina, dyspnoea, or syncope). The final score consisted of age, sex, Vmax, high-sensitivity troponin I concentration, and electrocardiographic strain pattern [c-statistic 0.85 (95% confidence interval 0.78-0.91), P < 0.001; Hosmer-Lemeshow χ(2) = 7.33, P = 0.50]. Patients in the outcome cohorts were classified according to the sensitivity and specificity of this score (both at 98%): low risk (probability score <7%), intermediate risk (7-57%), and high risk (>57%). In the internal outcome cohort, AS-related event rates were >10-fold higher in high-risk patients compared with those at low risk (23.9 vs. 2.1 events/100 patient-years, respectively; log rank P < 0.001). Similar findings were observed in the external outcome cohort (31.6 vs. 4.6 events/100 patient-years, respectively; log rank P < 0.001).
We propose a clinical score that predicts adverse outcomes in asymptomatic AS patients and potentially identifies high-risk patients who may benefit from early valve replacement.
心血管磁共振成像(CMR)检测到的室壁中层心肌纤维化是主动脉瓣狭窄(AS)早期心室失代偿及不良预后的一个标志物。我们旨在利用与室壁中层纤维化相关的变量开发并验证一种新型临床评分系统。
147例患者(主动脉峰值流速(Vmax)为3.9[3.2,4.4]m/s)接受CMR检查以确定室壁中层纤维化情况(CMR队列)。将与室壁中层纤维化显著相关的常规临床变量纳入多因素逻辑评分系统。我们在两个无症状患者的独立结局队列中验证了该评分系统的预后价值(内部队列:n = 127,随访10.3[5.7,11.2]年;外部队列:n = 289,随访2.6[1.6,4.5]年)。主要结局是AS相关事件的复合指标(心血管死亡、心力衰竭以及新发心绞痛、呼吸困难或晕厥)。最终评分系统包括年龄、性别、Vmax、高敏肌钙蛋白I浓度和心电图应变模式[c统计量为0.85(95%置信区间0.78 - 0.91),P < 0.001;Hosmer-Lemeshow χ(2)= 7.33,P = 0.50]。结局队列中的患者根据该评分系统的敏感性和特异性(均为98%)进行分类:低风险(概率评分<7%)、中风险(7 - 57%)和高风险(>57%)。在内部结局队列中,高风险患者的AS相关事件发生率比低风险患者高10倍以上(分别为23.9和2.1事件/100患者年;对数秩检验P < 0.001)。在外部结局队列中也观察到类似结果(分别为31.6和4.6事件/100患者年;对数秩检验P < 0.001)。
我们提出了一种临床评分系统,可预测无症状AS患者的不良预后,并有可能识别出可能从早期瓣膜置换中获益的高风险患者。