Nilsson Markus, Szczepankiewicz Filip, van Westen Danielle, Hansson Oskar
Lund University Bioimaging Center, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
Department of Medical Radiation Physics, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
PLoS One. 2015 Nov 3;10(11):e0141825. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0141825. eCollection 2015.
Conventional motion and eddy-current correction, where each diffusion-weighted volume is registered to a non diffusion-weighted reference, suffers from poor accuracy for high b-value data. An alternative approach is to extrapolate reference volumes from low b-value data. We aim to compare the performance of conventional and extrapolation-based correction of diffusional kurtosis imaging (DKI) data, and to demonstrate the impact of the correction approach on group comparison studies.
DKI was performed in patients with Parkinson's disease dementia (PDD), and healthy age-matched controls, using b-values of up to 2750 s/mm2. The accuracy of conventional and extrapolation-based correction methods was investigated. Parameters from DTI and DKI were compared between patients and controls in the cingulum and the anterior thalamic projection tract.
Conventional correction resulted in systematic registration errors for high b-value data. The extrapolation-based methods did not exhibit such errors, yielding more accurate tractography and up to 50% lower standard deviation in DKI metrics. Statistically significant differences were found between patients and controls when using the extrapolation-based motion correction that were not detected when using the conventional method.
We recommend that conventional motion and eddy-current correction should be abandoned for high b-value data in favour of more accurate methods using extrapolation-based references.
传统的运动和涡流校正方法是将每个扩散加权体积配准到一个非扩散加权参考图像上,对于高b值数据,其准确性较差。另一种方法是从低b值数据外推参考体积。我们旨在比较传统的基于配准和基于外推的扩散峰度成像(DKI)数据校正方法的性能,并证明校正方法对组间比较研究的影响。
对帕金森病痴呆(PDD)患者和年龄匹配的健康对照者进行DKI检查,使用的b值高达2750 s/mm2。研究了传统校正方法和基于外推的校正方法的准确性。比较了患者和对照者在扣带束和丘脑前投射束中的扩散张量成像(DTI)和DKI参数。
传统校正方法对高b值数据会产生系统性配准误差。基于外推的方法没有此类误差,能产生更准确的纤维束成像,且DKI指标的标准差降低了50%。使用基于外推的运动校正时,患者和对照者之间存在统计学显著差异,而使用传统方法时未检测到这些差异。
对于高b值数据,我们建议放弃传统的运动和涡流校正方法,转而采用基于外推参考的更准确方法。