Yon Katherine, Nettleton Sarah, Walters Kate, Lamahewa Kethakie, Buszewicz Marta
Research Department of Primary Care & Population Health, UCL, London, UK.
Department of Sociology, University of York, York, UK.
BMJ Open. 2015 Dec 1;5(12):e009593. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-009593.
To explore junior doctors' knowledge about and experiences of managing patients with medically unexplained symptoms (MUS) and to seek their recommendations for improved future training on this important topic about which they currently receive little education.
Qualitative study using in-depth interviews analysed using the framework method.
Participants were recruited from three North Thames London hospitals within the UK.
Twenty-two junior doctors undertaking the UK foundation two-year training programme (FY1/FY2).
The junior doctors interviewed identified a significant gap in their training on the topic of MUS, particularly in relation to their awareness of the topic, the appropriate level of investigations, possible psychological comorbidities, the formulation of suitable explanations for patients' symptoms and longer term management strategies. Many junior doctors expressed feelings of anxiety, frustration and a self-perceived lack of competency in this area, and spoke of over-investigating patients or avoiding patient contact altogether due to the challenging nature of MUS and a difficulty in managing the accompanying uncertainty. They also identified the negative attitudes of some senior clinicians and potential role models towards patients with MUS as a factor contributing to their own attitudes and management choices. Most reported a need for more training during the foundation years, and recommended interactive case-based group discussions with a focus on providing meaningful explanations to patients for their symptoms.
There is an urgent need to improve postgraduate training about the topics of MUS and avoiding over-investigation, as current training does not equip junior doctors with the necessary knowledge and skills to effectively and confidently manage patients in these areas. Training needs to focus on practical skill development to increase clinical knowledge in areas such as delivering suitable explanations, and to incorporate individual management strategies to help junior doctors tolerate the uncertainty associated with MUS.
探讨初级医生对患有医学无法解释症状(MUS)患者的管理知识和经验,并就这一重要主题寻求他们对未来改进培训的建议,目前他们在该主题上接受的教育很少。
采用框架法对深入访谈进行分析的定性研究。
参与者从英国伦敦北部泰晤士河地区的三家医院招募。
22名正在参加英国为期两年的基础培训计划(FY1/FY2)的初级医生。
接受访谈的初级医生指出,他们在MUS主题培训方面存在重大差距,特别是在对该主题的认识、适当的检查水平、可能的心理合并症、为患者症状制定合适的解释以及长期管理策略方面。许多初级医生表示在这方面感到焦虑、沮丧,并自我感觉缺乏能力,他们提到由于MUS的挑战性以及难以应对随之而来的不确定性,对患者进行过度检查或完全避免与患者接触。他们还指出一些资深临床医生和潜在榜样对患有MUS的患者的消极态度是导致他们自己态度和管理选择的一个因素。大多数人报告在基础培训阶段需要更多培训,并建议进行基于案例的互动小组讨论,重点是为患者的症状提供有意义的解释。
迫切需要改进关于MUS主题和避免过度检查的研究生培训,因为目前的培训没有使初级医生具备有效且自信地管理这些领域患者所需的知识和技能。培训需要注重实践技能发展,以增加在提供合适解释等领域的临床知识,并纳入个性化管理策略,以帮助初级医生容忍与MUS相关的不确定性。