Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT, UK.
WIDER, School of Life Sciences, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL, UK.
Nature. 2015 Dec 3;528(7580):S102-8. doi: 10.1038/nature16042.
Countries in the Indian subcontinent have committed to reducing the incidence of kala-azar, a clinical manifestation of visceral leishmaniasis, to below 1 in 10,000 by 2020. We address the role of timing of use and accuracy of diagnostics in kala-azar control and elimination. We use empirical data on health-seeking behaviour and health-system performance from the Indian state of Bihar, Bangladesh and Nepal to parameterize a mathematical model. Diagnosis of cases is key to case management, control and surveillance. Treatment of cases prevents onward transmission, and we show that the differences in time to diagnosis in these three settings explain the observed differences in incidence. Shortening the time from health-care seeking to diagnosis is likely to lead to dramatic reductions in incidence in Bihar, bringing the incidence down to the levels seen in Bangladesh and Nepal. The results emphasize the importance of maintaining population and health-system awareness, particularly as transmission and disease incidence decline. We explore the possibility of diagnosing patients before the onset of clinical kala-azar (before 14 days fever), and show that this could have a marked impact on incidence, even for a moderately sensitive test. However, limited specificity (that results in false positives) is a major barrier to such a strategy. Diagnostic tests of high specificity used at an early stage of active infection, even if sensitivity is only moderate, could have a key role in the control of kala-azar, and prevent its resurgence when paired with the passive health-care system and tests of high sensitivity, such as the test for rK39 antibody response.
南亚各国承诺到 2020 年将黑热病(内脏利什曼病的临床表现)发病率降低到每 10000 人 1 人以下。我们研究了使用时间和诊断准确性在黑热病控制和消除方面的作用。我们利用印度比哈尔邦、孟加拉国和尼泊尔在求医行为和卫生系统绩效方面的经验数据,对数学模型进行参数化。诊断病例是病例管理、控制和监测的关键。治疗病例可防止疾病进一步传播,我们发现这三个地区在诊断时间上的差异解释了发病率的差异。缩短从求医到诊断的时间可能会导致比哈尔邦的发病率大幅下降,使其发病率降至孟加拉国和尼泊尔的水平。研究结果强调了保持人群和卫生系统意识的重要性,特别是在传播和疾病发病率下降的情况下。我们探讨了在出现临床黑热病(发热前 14 天)之前诊断患者的可能性,并表明即使测试敏感性仅为中等,这种方法也可能对发病率产生重大影响。然而,特异性有限(导致假阳性)是该策略的主要障碍。在活动性感染的早期阶段使用特异性高的诊断测试,即使敏感性仅为中等,也可能在黑热病控制方面发挥关键作用,并在与高敏感性的被动医疗保健系统和测试(如 rK39 抗体反应测试)结合使用时,防止其死灰复燃。