Sewell Mathew David, Wallace Charlie, Malagelada Francesc, Gibson Alex, Noordeen Hilali, Tucker Stewart, Molloy Sean, Lehovsky Jan
From the Spinal Deformity Unit, Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital, Stanmore, UK.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2015 Dec;94(49):e1907. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000001907.
Spinal fusion is used to treat scoliosis in children with cerebral palsy (CP). Following intervention, the WHO considers activity and participation should be assessed to guide intervention and assess the effects. This study assesses whether spinal fusion for scoliosis improves activity and participation for children with severe CP.Retrospective cohort study of 70 children (39M:31F) with GMFCS level 4/5 CP and significant scoliosis. Thirty-six underwent observational and/or brace treatment as the sole treatment for their scoliosis, and 34 underwent surgery. Children in the operative group were older and had worse scoliosis than those in the observational group. Questionnaire and radiographic data were recorded over a 2-year period. The ASKp was used to measure activity and participation.In the observational group, Cobb angle and pelvic obliquity increased from 51 (40-90) and 10 (0-30) to 70 (43-111) and 14 (0-37). Mean ASKp decreased from 16.3 (1-38) to 14.2 (1-36). In the operative group, Cobb angle and pelvic obliquity decreased from 81 (50-131) and 14 (1-35) to 38 (10-76) and 9 (0-24). Mean ASKp increased from 10.5 (0-29) to 15.9 (3-38). Spinal-related pain correlated most with change in activity and participation in both groups. There was no difference in mobility, GMFCS level, feeding or communication in either group before and after treatment.In children with significant scoliosis and CP classified within GMFCS levels 4 and 5, spinal fusion was associated with an improvement in activity and participation, whereas nonoperative treatment was associated with a small reduction. Pain should be carefully assessed to guide intervention.
脊柱融合术用于治疗患有脑瘫(CP)的儿童的脊柱侧弯。干预后,世界卫生组织认为应评估活动和参与情况,以指导干预并评估效果。本研究评估脊柱融合术治疗脊柱侧弯是否能改善重度脑瘫儿童的活动和参与情况。
对70名患有GMFCS 4/5级脑瘫且有明显脊柱侧弯的儿童(39名男性:31名女性)进行回顾性队列研究。36名儿童接受观察和/或支具治疗作为脊柱侧弯的唯一治疗方法,34名儿童接受手术治疗。手术组儿童比观察组儿童年龄更大,脊柱侧弯更严重。在两年时间内记录问卷和影像学数据。使用ASKp来测量活动和参与情况。
在观察组中,Cobb角和骨盆倾斜度从51(40 - 90)和10(0 - 30)增加到70(43 - 111)和14(0 - 37)。平均ASKp从16.3(1 - 38)降至14.2(1 - 36)。在手术组中,Cobb角和骨盆倾斜度从81(50 - 131)和14(1 - 35)降至38(10 - 76)和9(0 - 24)。平均ASKp从10.5(0 - 29)增至15.9(3 - 38)。两组中与脊柱相关的疼痛与活动和参与情况的变化相关性最大。两组治疗前后在活动能力、GMFCS分级、进食或沟通方面均无差异。
在GMFCS 4级和5级的明显脊柱侧弯和脑瘫儿童中,脊柱融合术与活动和参与情况的改善相关,而非手术治疗则与小幅下降相关。应仔细评估疼痛以指导干预。