Bhadelia R A, Patz S, Heilman C, Khatami D, Kasper E, Zhao Y, Madan N
From the Department of Radiology (R.A.B., D.K.), Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Department of Radiology (S.P.), Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2016 May;37(5):825-30. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A4629. Epub 2015 Dec 24.
Invasive pressure studies have suggested that CSF flow across the foramen magnum may transiently decrease after coughing in patients with symptomatic Chiari I malformation. The purpose of this exploratory study was to demonstrate this phenomenon noninvasively by assessing CSF flow response to coughing in symptomatic patients with Chiari I malformation by using MR pencil beam imaging and to compare the response with that in healthy participants.
Eight symptomatic patients with Chiari I malformation and 6 healthy participants were studied by using MR pencil beam imaging with a temporal resolution of ∼50 ms. Patients and healthy participants were scanned for 90 seconds (without cardiac gating) to continuously record cardiac cycle-related CSF flow waveforms in real-time during resting, coughing, and postcoughing periods. CSF flow waveform amplitude, CSF stroke volume, and CSF flow rate (CSF Flow Rate = CSF Stroke Volume × Heart Rate) in the resting and immediate postcoughing periods were determined and compared between patients and healthy participants.
There was no significant difference in CSF flow waveform amplitude, CSF stroke volume, and the CSF flow rate between patients with Chiari I malformation and healthy participants during rest. However, immediately after coughing, a significant decrease in CSF flow waveform amplitude (P < .001), CSF stroke volume (P = .001), and CSF flow rate (P = .001) was observed in patients with Chiari I malformation but not in the healthy participants.
Real-time MR imaging noninvasively showed a transient decrease in CSF flow across the foramen magnum after coughing in symptomatic patients with Chiari I malformation, a phenomenon not seen in healthy participants. Our results provide preliminary evidence that the physiology-based imaging method used here has the potential to be an objective clinical test to differentiate symptomatic from asymptomatic patients with Chiari I malformation.
侵入性压力研究表明,症状性Chiari I畸形患者咳嗽后,经枕骨大孔的脑脊液流动可能会短暂减少。本探索性研究的目的是通过使用磁共振铅笔束成像评估症状性Chiari I畸形患者咳嗽后脑脊液流动反应,以无创方式证明这一现象,并将该反应与健康参与者的反应进行比较。
对8例症状性Chiari I畸形患者和6名健康参与者使用时间分辨率约为50毫秒的磁共振铅笔束成像进行研究。对患者和健康参与者进行90秒扫描(无心脏门控),以在静息、咳嗽和咳嗽后阶段实时连续记录与心动周期相关的脑脊液流动波形。确定并比较患者和健康参与者在静息期和咳嗽后即刻的脑脊液流动波形幅度、脑脊液每搏量和脑脊液流速(脑脊液流速=脑脊液每搏量×心率)。
在静息状态下,Chiari I畸形患者与健康参与者之间的脑脊液流动波形幅度、脑脊液每搏量和脑脊液流速无显著差异。然而,咳嗽后即刻,Chiari I畸形患者的脑脊液流动波形幅度(P<.001)、脑脊液每搏量(P=.001)和脑脊液流速(P=.001)显著降低,而健康参与者未出现这种情况。
实时磁共振成像无创显示,症状性Chiari I畸形患者咳嗽后经枕骨大孔的脑脊液流动出现短暂减少,健康参与者未出现此现象。我们的结果提供了初步证据,表明此处使用的基于生理学的成像方法有可能成为区分症状性与无症状性Chiari I畸形患者的客观临床检查方法。